Yankees Cut Luis Gil, Their 2024 Rookie of the Year, at the Non-Tender Deadline
On this page6
The New York Yankees cut Luis Gil loose on Friday, and the name on the list was the one that stopped people scrolling. Gil was the American League’s Rookie of the Year in 2024, a 15-game winner with a 96.6 mph fastball. Two seasons later, after a lat strain and a shoulder problem wrecked his next two years, the Yankees decided not to offer him a contract for 2027 at all. He is a free agent now, one of 44 players non-tendered across baseball on Friday.
What happened to Gil on Friday?
The Yankees declined to tender him a contract by the 5 p.m. ET deadline, which means he becomes a free agent instead of going through salary arbitration. Gil earned $2,162,500 in 2026 and was eligible for arbitration, which would have meant a raise despite a season in which he barely pitched. The Yankees chose the other option. He was the headliner of the non-tender list, and the move landed on the same chaotic day the Twins traded Royce Lewis to the Dodgers and the Mets’ reported nine-year, almost $400 million offer to Tarik Skubal became public.
How good was Gil in 2024?
Very good, and briefly one of the best stories in baseball. The 28-year-old right-hander went 15-7 with a 3.50 ERA in 29 starts, striking out 171 batters in 151 and two-thirds innings. His four-seam fastball averaged 96.6 mph, and he was voted the American League’s top rookie. The one flaw was obvious even then: he walked a major-league-high 77 batters, a wildness that made his starts an adventure. But the stuff was so good that the Yankees built their 2024 rotation around him, and he finished the year as a genuine frontline starter rather than a pleasant surprise.
What went wrong after the breakout?
His body gave out. A lat strain sidelined him for much of 2025, when he managed 11 starts and went 4-1 with a 3.32 ERA, and right shoulder inflammation cost him most of 2026. He spent much of last season in the minors and made only nine big-league appearances for the Yankees, four starts and five in relief, going 1-2 with a 4.61 ERA. Two seasons, 20 big-league outings combined, after a 29-start Rookie of the Year campaign. The Yankees kept waiting for the 2024 pitcher to come back, and in the end they ran out of patience at the exact moment his price was about to go up.
Why would the Yankees cut a former Rookie of the Year?
Because arbitration pays for what you did, not what you might do again. Gil’s 2026 salary was $2,162,500, and an arbitration raise would have paid him more for a pitcher who has thrown so little in two years. The Yankees evidently decided the money was better spent elsewhere, and that a roster spot matters more than a lottery ticket on a shoulder. It is the cold arithmetic of the non-tender deadline: teams cut players they like every year when the projected salary outruns the recent production. Gil joins a long list of Rookie of the Year winners whose careers took a sharp turn, and the Yankees will now watch to see whether another club bets on the arm.
Who else was cut loose on Friday?
The list had other notable names. Washington cut 2023 All-Star Josiah Gray, who was limited to two games in 2024 by a torn ulnar collateral ligament and three September appearances this year by a flexor strain, and had been designated for assignment on Tuesday. St. Louis cut former first-round pick Nolan Gorman, who hit 27 homers in 2023. The Twins cut Bailey Ober, Trevor Larnach and Matt Wallner on the same day they traded Lewis. Seattle cut Luke Raley, who hit 13 homers in his first 53 games with a .929 OPS in 2026 before season-ending flexor tendon surgery. The Yankees also let go of reliever Fernando Cruz, who did not pitch after August 25 because of a partially torn ulnar collateral ligament. The biggest surprises were the players who stayed: Boston kept Jarren Duran and the Mets kept Mark Vientos, both widely rumoured non-tender candidates.
What happens to Gil now?
He tests the open market, joining a free-agent pool that already included 183 players who became free agents after the World Series. A team that believes in the 2024 form and the fastball can sign him without giving anything up, and a low-cost, incentive-heavy deal is the obvious shape of it. The Yankees are free to bring him back too, at a lower number than arbitration would have paid. This year’s Rookie of the Year winners were crowned while Gil was fighting for innings in the minors, which says plenty about how fast baseball moves on. Gil is 28, his arm is the same one that won 15 games two years ago, and now somebody has to decide whether the last two seasons were the injury or the pitcher.
Frequently asked questions
What does it mean to be non-tendered?+
It means the Yankees declined to offer Gil a contract for 2027, so he becomes a free agent instead of going through salary arbitration. Teams must tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players by the deadline or cut them loose, and 44 players across baseball were non-tendered on Friday.
How good was Gil in 2024?+
He was the American League's Rookie of the Year, going 15-7 with a 3.50 ERA in 29 starts for the Yankees. He struck out 171 batters in 151 and two-thirds innings with a four-seam fastball averaging 96.6 mph, though he also walked a major-league-high 77 batters.
What happened to Gil after 2024?+
Injuries took his rotation spot away. A lat strain sidelined him for much of 2025, when he went 4-1 with a 3.32 ERA in 11 starts, and right shoulder inflammation cost him most of 2026, when he spent much of the year in the minors and made only nine big-league appearances.
How much would Gil have cost the Yankees?+
He earned $2,162,500 in 2026 and was eligible for arbitration, which would have meant a raise despite his limited season. The Yankees decided the price was not worth it for a pitcher who has thrown so little in two years, so he now tests the open market as a free agent.
Who else was non-tendered on Friday?+
The biggest names were 2023 All-Star Josiah Gray, cut by Washington after two injury-hit years, and former first-round pick Nolan Gorman of St. Louis, who hit 27 homers in 2023. The Twins cut Bailey Ober, Trevor Larnach and Matt Wallner, and the Yankees also let go of reliever Fernando Cruz.
What happens to Gil now?+
He is a free agent and can sign with any club, joining a market that already included 183 players who became free agents after the World Series. A team betting on his 2024 form and his 96.6 mph fastball could offer a low-cost deal, with the Yankees among the clubs free to bring him back.
Was Gil the only Yankee cut?+
No. New York also non-tendered reliever Fernando Cruz, who did not pitch after August 25 because of a partially torn ulnar collateral ligament and said he would try to return without surgery. Cruz, 36, went 4-6 with a 3.13 ERA and two saves in 61 appearances in 2026, striking out 67.
Sources
- NBC Sports: Former Rookie of the Year Luis Gil and 2023 All-Star Josiah Gray among 44 non-tender free agents (Gil cut loose by the Yankees, the 44 non-tenders, the 2024 numbers, the 2025 lat strain and 2026 shoulder inflammation, the $2,162,500 salary, Cruz and Gray)
- USA Today: MLB's chaotic day sees notable names non-tendered, trades, more Tarik Skubal news (Gil as the Yankees' dumped former Rookie of the Year, the 44 non-tenders, Gorman, Ober, Larnach, Raley, the surprise tenders Duran and Vientos)
- theScore: MLB non-tender deadline tracker: 44 players hit free agency (the full 44-player list, Gil, Gray, Gorman, Fry, Larnach, Ober, Raley, Schneider, Sears, Cousins, Sulser, De La Cruz)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 162-0 — Draft nine and see if your roster can survive a flawless 162-game MLB season.
- Explore all our games →
- Analyze a trade — Compare both sides of a fantasy baseball trade before you accept.
- Run the MLB predictor — Simulate the MLB postseason bracket down to a World Series champion.
- Open the ERA calculator — Work out earned run average from earned runs and innings pitched — handles the .1/.2 thirds convention.
- Explore all our free sports tools →
Related baseball guides
View all →
Ben Rice Becomes the First Yankees DH Named to an All-MLB Team
Ben Rice was named to the All-MLB Second Team after hitting 41 home runs in 2026, becoming the first Yankees designated hitter to receive the honor since the awards began in 2019.
Bob Boone, Four-Time All-Star and Father of Yankees Manager Aaron Boone, Dies at 78
Bob Boone, the four-time All-Star catcher who won the 1980 World Series with the Phillies and anchored baseball's first three-generation family, has died at 78.
Rumor: Teruaki Sato Draws a Five-Team Race With a December 1 Deadline to Sign
Reports link Japanese Triple Crown winner Teruaki Sato to the Dodgers, Mets, Padres, Phillies and Yankees, but the December 1 lockout gives him weeks, not months, to sign.
Goose Gossage Calls Jazz Chisholm Jr. a 'Clown' Over Yankees Lollipop Row
Hall of Famer Goose Gossage told NJ.com that Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a disgrace to the Yankees after the lollipop incident, reviving a debate about what wearing pinstripes means.
Spike Lee Breaks Silence on Yankees Suite Clash and Hate Mail
Spike Lee says the Yankee Stadium suite confrontation in September was only a glimpse of the abuse he has faced, telling Variety he still receives hate mail over his views.
Pat Murphy's Viral Yankees Jab to Jake Bauers: 'Playing for Yourselves'
Brewers manager Pat Murphy told free-agent-to-be Jake Bauers to remember Milwaukee's way after the World Series clincher, taking a swipe at the Yankees team Bauers left behind.