SportsMonkie.com
Baseball

Pat Murphy's Viral Yankees Jab to Jake Bauers: 'Playing for Yourselves'

By SportsMonkie Baseball Desk Updated November 3, 2026
File photo from 20 May 2013: Pat Murphy, then managing the Tucson Padres, arguing a call on the field. It was not taken at the World Series celebration and does not show the exchange with Jake Bauers.
Image: Pat Murphy on May 20, 2013.jpg by Minda Haas · via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Share this guide
On this page7
  1. 01What did Murphy actually say?
  2. 02Why did the Yankees jab land so hard?
  3. 03How did fans react?
  4. 04What does this mean for Bauers’ free agency?
  5. 05Has anyone from the Yankees responded?
  6. 06Has Murphy apologised? (Update, October 29)
  7. 07Update, November 3: Murphy calls Cashman himself

Pat Murphy had just won the first World Series in Milwaukee Brewers history when he delivered the line that will follow the celebration. As Jake Bauers handed him the ball from the final out of the 4-1 Game 5 win over the Tampa Bay Rays, Murphy told the first baseman he was about to get rich, then took a swipe at the team Bauers used to play for. Just remember, he said, when you are on that Yankees team where everyone is playing for themselves, this is the way Milwaukee used to do it. Spectrum News 1 Wisconsin cameras caught the exchange, and within hours it was everywhere.

What did Murphy actually say?

The quote, as USA Today reports it, with the expletives softened: “You’re gonna be a rich (expletive). Just remember when you’re on that horse (expletive) Yankee team and you’re all playing for yourselves … Just remember, this is the way we used to do it.” Bauers, who had just caught the final out, laughed. Al Bat’s account of the clip adds his reply: “You’re not getting rid of me that easy.”

That reply matters, because it tells you how the exchange landed in the room. This was not a manager scolding a player. It was a championship celebration, a ball changing hands, and a joke with a point. Murphy was telling Bauers to remember the feeling, and using the Yankees, the team that let Bauers go, as the contrast. Bauers got the joke, and so did most of the internet.

Why did the Yankees jab land so hard?

Because the two halves of Bauers’ career make Murphy’s point for him. In New York in 2023, Bauers hit .202 in 84 games, with 12 home runs and 30 RBI, Heavy reports. In Milwaukee in 2026, he hit .266 with 26 home runs, 86 RBI and 93 runs in 144 games, then was named NLCS MVP in the sweep of the two-time defending champion Los Angeles Dodgers. Same player, different team, different result. Murphy did not need to argue the case. The numbers did it.

The jab also landed because of who the Yankees are in this story. They have won 27 World Series titles but none in 17 years, and their season ended well before Milwaukee’s run to the first championship in franchise history. Murphy, a 67-year-old manager who spent four decades in the game before this title, was not just trolling a rival. He was drawing the line the whole Brewers season drew, the same line he drew after the NLCS when he called his Brewers gamers, not Hall of Famers, after sweeping the Dodgers: a team built on long at-bats, clean defence and togetherness against a sport that increasingly rewards individual stardom.

How did fans react?

With unusual agreement, including from the fans Murphy was teasing. Heavy collected reactions from Yankees supporters who said Murphy was correct, that the quote should play on a loop wherever general manager Brian Cashman consumes his news, and that they were not bothered because they wanted change themselves. That is the rare sports insult that works as a consensus: Brewers fans loved it, neutral fans laughed, and a chunk of Yankees fans nodded along.

It helps that Murphy is not a stranger to this kind of moment. He has already gone viral this postseason for cursing Jackson Merrill on live television during his own mid-game interview, and for FaceTiming Chris Russo after the Brewers declined an interview request, and his unfiltered style is part of why Milwaukee’s run felt so personal to its fans. The Yankees jab is different in one way, though: it was not a broadcast interview but a clubhouse exchange caught by a celebration camera, which is why it spread as a clip rather than a quote.

What does this mean for Bauers’ free agency?

Quite a lot, in the narrow sense that matters. Bauers enters the winter as one of the market’s available power bats after a career year, though USA Today notes he is not among the top 10 overall free agents in a class headlined by pitchers Tarik Skubal, Michael King and Freddy Peralta. Teams needing a left-handed bat with postseason pedigree will call, and Murphy’s public pitch, remember how we do it here, doubles as a recruiting line.

Milwaukee’s side of the equation is simpler. The Brewers return almost the whole championship roster for 2027, and they celebrate with a parade through downtown Milwaukee on Friday, October 30. Whether Bauers is on the next roster is an offseason question, but Murphy has already made his case in the most public way possible: on camera, holding the final-out ball, telling his first baseman not to forget what this version of baseball felt like.

Has anyone from the Yankees responded?

Not so far. No response from the Yankees, Brian Cashman or Aaron Boone has been reported, and there is no obvious reason to expect one. Murphy’s remark targeted a style of play rather than an individual, and New York’s season has been over for weeks. The silence is also the point: the clip does not need a reply to work. It is a championship manager, in the happiest moment of his career, telling his player that the team he left behind never understood what the team he joined just proved. That is the kind of line that outlives the celebration, and it is why, by Thursday morning, it was the most shared moment of the World Series aftermath.

Has Murphy apologised? (Update, October 29)

Update, October 29: not himself, not yet, but his closer says he feels terrible about it. Brewers star Trevor Megill told The Pat McAfee Show on Thursday that Murphy feels terrible about the Yankees diss, Yardbarker and ClutchPoints both report, quoting Megill directly: “He feels terrible, Pat. He feels terrible.” Megill added that he is sure Murphy will apologise to general manager Brian Cashman and the people over there, and that Murphy genuinely just feels terrible about it.

The distinction matters. Megill is predicting an apology, not reporting one, and Murphy himself has not yet said sorry in public. Megill also stressed the context the clip stripped away: Murphy did not say it to the media, a celebration camera simply picked up a private exchange between a manager and his player, and he surely did not intend for it to become a talking point across baseball. That is the closest thing to a Brewers response so far, and it reads less like damage control than like a team-mate explaining a man he knows. Whether Murphy follows Megill’s prediction with an apology of his own is now the next beat of a story that started with a ball changing hands.

Update, November 3: Murphy calls Cashman himself

Megill’s prediction came true within days. Murphy told The Post’s Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman on The Show podcast that he called Yankees general manager Brian Cashman right away when he heard the clip had got out, the New York Post reports, and that he had a good conversation in which he tried to explain he was not talking about the 2026 Yankees. TheScore, citing ESPN’s account of the same appearance, adds Murphy’s own summary: “I regret saying it.” Murphy also gave the joke its backstory, the Post reports: after every celebration he would shake Bauers’ hand and tell him he was going to leave Milwaukee, get rich and forget how the Brewers did things, because Bauers had played for the Yankees in 2023. He called Cashman a “good guy” and did not go into detail about the conversation itself. The apology closes the one open question this article carried since October 29, and it does so on Murphy’s own terms: a private joke, caught by a celebration camera, owned in public once he realised it had travelled.

Share this article

Frequently asked questions

What exactly did Pat Murphy say to Jake Bauers?+

As Bauers handed him the ball from the final out of the Game 5 win, Murphy told him he was going to be a rich man, USA Today reports, then added: 'Just remember when you're on that horse (expletive) Yankee team and you're all playing for yourselves ... Just remember, this is the way we used to do it.' Spectrum News 1 Wisconsin cameras caught the exchange during the on-field celebration, Al Bat reports.

Why did Murphy bring up the Yankees?+

Bauers played for New York in 2023 before joining Milwaukee in 2024, and he is about to hit free agency after the best season of his career. Murphy's point was about team culture: the Brewers won with discipline and togetherness, while, in his telling, the Yankees team Bauers left behind played as individuals. Bauers laughed it off, Al Bat reports, replying that Murphy was not getting rid of him that easily.

How good was Jake Bauers' season?+

He hit .266 with 26 home runs, 86 RBI, 93 runs scored and 11 stolen bases in 144 games, USA Today reports, then earned NLCS MVP honours in Milwaukee's sweep of the two-time defending champion Los Angeles Dodgers. In New York in 2023 he had hit just .202 in 84 games, with 12 home runs and 30 RBI, Heavy reports, which is why the contrast stung.

How did fans react to the clip?+

Mostly with agreement, including from Yankees fans. Heavy collected reactions from supporters who said Murphy was correct, that the quote belonged on a loop wherever general manager Brian Cashman gets his news, and that they were not even bothered because they wanted change too. The clip spread through several accounts on social media within hours of the clincher.

Is this the first time Murphy has gone viral for swearing on camera?+

No. Murphy has made a habit of unfiltered moments this postseason, including [cursing Jackson Merrill on live television during his own mid-game interview](/pat-murphy-curses-jackson-merrill-live-interview/) earlier in October. The Yankees jab is different in one respect: it was a private clubhouse exchange caught by a celebration camera, not a broadcast interview.

What happens next for Bauers and the Brewers?+

Bauers enters free agency this winter as one of the market's power bats, though USA Today notes he is not among the top 10 overall free agents in a class headlined by pitchers Tarik Skubal, Michael King and Freddy Peralta. Milwaukee, which returns almost its whole championship roster, holds a parade on Friday, October 30, and Bauers' decision will be one of the offseason's early watches.

Has Pat Murphy apologised for the Yankees jab?+

Yes, himself, on November 3. Murphy told The Post's 'The Show' podcast that he called Yankees general manager Brian Cashman right away when he heard the clip had got out, the New York Post reports, and that he tried to explain he was not talking about the 2026 Yankees. TheScore, citing ESPN's account of the same podcast appearance, adds Murphy's words: 'I regret saying it.' The apology resolves the prediction closer Trevor Megill made on The Pat McAfee Show that Murphy would apologise to Cashman.

Did the Yankees respond to Murphy's jab?+

No response from the Yankees, general manager Brian Cashman or manager Aaron Boone has been reported. Murphy's remark was aimed at the Yankees' style of play rather than any individual, and New York's season ended weeks before the World Series, so there is no obvious forum for a reply unless someone chooses to give one.

Sources

Play & tools

Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.

Related baseball guides

View all →
File photo from September 27, 2023: American Family Field in Milwaukee before a Brewers game, the stadium where Murphy spoke at World Series Media Day. It is a 2023 file photo and does not show Media Day or the FaceTime call. The cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY-SA 4.0 licence as the original.
Baseball

Pat Murphy FaceTimed Chris Russo After the Brewers Declined His Interview Request

Chris Russo ranted on First Take after the Brewers declined his Pat Murphy interview request in five minutes. Murphy heard about it, called him, and did the show by FaceTime.

File photo from 30 October 2026: Sal Frelick at the Milwaukee Brewers World Series victory parade, wearing a champions hoodie and holding a can. It is not a photograph of the breakfast encounter described in this article.
Baseball

Brewers Fans Keep Handing Sal Frelick Beers at 9 a.m. After His 100,000-Beer Parade Promise

Sal Frelick told Milwaukee fans at the World Series parade he would drink 100,000 beers, and now strangers keep handing him cans at breakfast, he told Pardon My Take.

File photo from 20 November 2011: Wisconsin Avenue in downtown Milwaukee, looking toward the Milwaukee Art Museum's white wings. It was not taken at the 2026 World Series parade.
Baseball

Brewers Parade Their First World Series Title Through a Packed Downtown Milwaukee

Milwaukee celebrated its first World Series title with a downtown parade and lakefront rally, as 175,000 packed the Summerfest grounds and players stopped at the Bob Uecker mural.

File photo from September 13, 2011: Bob Uecker, wearing a USS Milwaukee ball cap he had just been given, talks with Secretary of the Navy Ray Mabus on the field at Miller Park, now American Family Field. It predates the 2026 World Series by 15 years.
Baseball

Bob Uecker's Family Tells Milwaukee 'Let's Win Our Way' as the Brewers Reach the World Series

Two days before the Brewers' first World Series game since 1982, the Uecker family released a letter through the club: pride, longing for Bob, and a message for the players, the staff and the fans.

File photo from 13 June 2021: Jake Bauers of the Seattle Mariners slides into third base at Progressive Field. It was not taken at the Red Sox signing. The 16:9 cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY 2.0 licence.
Baseball

Jake Bauers Goes From Nearly Retiring to a $58 Million Red Sox Deal

Two years after preparing to retire, Jake Bauers has agreed a four-year, $58 million deal with Boston, turning down Milwaukee's $23.15 million qualifying offer.

File photo from 20 May 2013: Pat Murphy, then managing the Tucson Padres, arguing a call on the field. It was not taken at the hospital or the awards announcement and does not show the 2026 season. The 16:9 cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY 2.0 licence as the original.
Baseball

Pat Murphy Wins Third Straight Manager of the Year From a Hospital Bed

Pat Murphy became the first manager ever to win three straight Manager of the Year awards, accepting the honour from a hospital bed a day after hip replacement surgery.