SportsMonkie.com
Ice Hockey

Tavares' Tying Goal Wiped Out on Review as Leafs Lose 1-0 to Oilers

By SportsMonkie Ice Hockey Desk Updated November 15, 2026
File photo from 3 March 2018: John Tavares in an Islanders jersey during a game against Pittsburgh. It was not taken at the Oilers game in Toronto.
Image: John Tavares 2018-03-03 19541 by Michael Miller · via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Share this guide
On this page6
  1. 01What happened on the Tavares goal?
  2. 02Why did the review take four and a half minutes?
  3. 03What did Tavares, Hiller and Levi say?
  4. 04How bad is the Leafs’ homestand now?
  5. 05What did the loss do to Toronto’s season?
  6. 06What happens next for the Leafs?

John Tavares appeared to tie the game one minute into the third period, but officials overturned the goal after a four-and-a-half-minute video review ruled he deflected the puck with his stick above the crossbar. Edmonton won 1-0, Toronto finished a six-game homestand without a point, and the Leafs fell to last place in the Atlantic Division.

What happened on the Tavares goal?

Toronto trailed 1-0 when William Nylander fired a point shot early in the third period and Tavares deflected it past Devon Levi. The officials on the ice called it a goal, the crowd at Scotiabank Arena roared, and then the play went to review. After four and a half minutes, the call was overturned. The ruling was that Tavares contacted the puck above the crossbar, which makes the deflection illegal under the high-stick rule. The goal came off the board, the 1-0 score stood, and Edmonton held on for its fourth straight win.

Why did the review take four and a half minutes?

Because the angles did not settle it quickly. The broadcast replays never showed a frame that made the call obvious, and the officials kept looking. Levi said he expected the goal to be overturned right away, telling reporters he saw the tip go over his head and knew it was a high stick, and that he was surprised how long the review took. Hiller saw the opposite from the bench. “I stared at my monitor for a minute. I couldn’t see anything that said it wasn’t,” he said. “They stared at the monitor for four and a half or five minutes and obviously they found something that I didn’t see looking down there.” The length of the review became the story as much as the ruling: if the evidence was conclusive, fans asked, why did it take so long to find it.

What did Tavares, Hiller and Levi say?

Tavares said he felt good about the goal when it went in and during the review, then added he did not know what the explanation was or exactly what the league saw. It was his fifth game without a point since returning from a lower-body injury, and he admitted the homestand has been challenging, saying the team feels for its fans and the difficulty it has had at home. Hiller was blunter. “That one hurt,” he said, and insisted his team deserved better than the homestand gave them. Levi, at the other end, had the calmest night of the three: 19 saves, his first NHL shutout, and a 9-1-0 start to his Oilers career that is the best 10-game start by a goalie in franchise history.

How bad is the Leafs’ homestand now?

It is the worst in the club’s history by the only measure that counts. Toronto lost all six games in regulation and was outscored 23-9 by Utah, Montreal, New Jersey, Colorado, Minnesota and Edmonton. The Leafs have lost eight of nine since October 26, have been shut out twice in their last four games, and generated just 10 power-play chances across the six games, scoring once. They woke up Sunday eight points outside a playoff spot despite playing 14 of 22 games at home, where they are 4-9-1. Goalie Anthony Stolarz summed it up in one word: “It sucks.” The night still had one bright spot for Toronto, which was also the cruel part. Stolarz stopped 22 of 23 shots in his first back-to-back starts of the season, and the Leafs held the NHL’s third-highest-scoring team to a single goal. They lost anyway.

What did the loss do to Toronto’s season?

It turned a slump into a standings problem. The Leafs are last in the Atlantic Division, and the gap to a playoff spot is now eight points in mid-November. The injuries have not helped: winger Kirill Marchenko has been week-to-week since getting hurt on October 26, and defenceman Morgan Rielly has not been on the ice since a lower-body injury on November 9. The one piece of the night that belonged to Edmonton was historic in its own right. McDavid’s assist on the Bouchard goal took him to 50 points in 21 games, making him only the fifth player in NHL history to reach 50 points in 21 games or fewer, alongside Wayne Gretzky, Mario Lemieux, Bernie Nicholls and Mike Bossy. He is one game from tying Dany Heatley’s 22-game season-opening point streak from 2005-06. The game was also Mike Babcock’s first in Toronto since the Leafs fired him on November 20, 2019, a footnote the home crowd did not get to enjoy.

What happens next for the Leafs?

The schedule finally eases. Toronto goes to Chicago to play the Blackhawks on Tuesday, then hosts the Los Angeles Kings on Thursday and the Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday. All three sit below the Leafs in the overall standings, and Toronto already beat Columbus earlier this season. Stolarz called it gut-check time and said the team has to look in the mirror, while Tavares vowed the group will get through it and be better for it. The disallowed goal will keep being argued online, where clips of the review have already split fans between those who say the stick was clearly high and those who say a goal called on the ice should stand when the evidence takes five minutes to find. The standings do not care about the argument. Toronto has to win in Chicago, or the homestand story becomes a season story.

Connor Bedard returned a month early for his captain’s debut this season, and the Leafs’ own season has had its share of officiating flashpoints already, from the Lauzon hit on Ekman-Larsson that drew no penalty to Frank Nazar’s match penalty for a high hit on Bo Horvat. Hiller has been in the middle of those too: he admitted benching rookie Gavin McKenna was his mistake after the Leafs blew a 4-2 lead to San Jose. Saturday was a different kind of admission, that a coach can watch a replay for a minute and see a good goal while the league watches for five and sees a high stick.

Share this article

Frequently asked questions

Was John Tavares' stick above the crossbar?+

The officials ruled it was. After reviewing the play for four and a half minutes, they determined Tavares contacted the puck with his stick above the crossbar when he deflected William Nylander's point shot past Devon Levi. Tavares said he felt good about the goal when it went in and during the review, and coach Jim Hiller said he could not see anything on his monitor that showed it was not a goal.

Why was the goal overturned if it was called a goal on the ice?+

A goal called on the ice can still be overturned when video review produces conclusive evidence of an infraction. The on-ice officials called it a goal, then reviewed the deflection and decided the stick was above the crossbar, which makes the goal illegal under the high-stick rule. The length of the review, four and a half minutes, is what fuelled the argument that the evidence was not conclusive enough to overturn the call.

How long did the video review last?+

Four and a half minutes, according to TSN's Mark Masters, with some accounts putting it closer to five. The delay quieted the Scotiabank Arena crowd. Levi said he was surprised it took so long because he felt sure from the start it was a high stick, while Hiller said the officials stared at the monitor for four and a half or five minutes and found something he had not seen from the bench.

Who scored the Oilers' only goal?+

Evan Bouchard scored at 15:34 of the second period, taking a backhand pass from Connor McDavid at the point and beating Anthony Stolarz glove side with a slap shot. It was the only goal of the game. McDavid's assist extended his season-opening point streak to 21 games, and he leads the NHL with 50 points in 21 games.

How good was Devon Levi in the Oilers net?+

Levi made 19 saves for his first NHL shutout and improved to 9-1-0 in his career with Edmonton, the best 10-game start by a goalie in franchise history. He stopped Auston Matthews alone in the slot with four seconds left after Toronto pulled Stolarz for an extra attacker. Stolarz made 22 saves at the other end in his first back-to-back starts of the season.

How bad is the Leafs' homestand now?+

Toronto lost all six games in regulation and was outscored 23-9, the first time the club has gone pointless through a six-game homestand. The Leafs have lost eight of nine games since October 26, have been shut out twice in their last four, and sit eight points outside a playoff spot despite playing 14 of 22 games at home, where they are 4-9-1.

When do the Maple Leafs play next?+

Toronto goes to Chicago to play the Blackhawks on Tuesday, then returns home to host the Los Angeles Kings on Thursday and the Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday. The schedule eases after a brutal stretch: the six homestand opponents were Utah, Montreal, New Jersey, Colorado, Minnesota and Edmonton, and the next three opponents all sit below Toronto in the overall league standings.

What did the fans make of the disallowed goal?+

Clips of the review spread fast on social media, with Leafs fans calling the call a robbery and arguing the broadcast angles never proved the stick was high. Oilers fans answered that the overhead angle and the crossbar line graphic settled it. The argument split along the same line as the review itself: one side saw a goal that took too long to erase, the other saw a correct call that took too long to confirm.

Sources

Play & tools

Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.

Related ice hockey guides

View all →
File photo from 3 October 2021: Vasily Podkolzin in a Vancouver Canucks jersey during a warm-up skate at Rogers Arena. It was not taken at the Oilers game and does not show the fight. The 16:9 cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY-SA 4.0 licence.
Ice Hockey

Podkolzin Ejected for 'One-Man Fight' After Defending McDavid

Vasily Podkolzin was ejected for a 'one-man fight' after defending Connor McDavid against Anaheim, the only player penalised for fighting as the Ducks scored on the power play.

File photo: Darren Raddysh in a blue Syracuse Crunch jersey on the ice during the 2023 AHL All-Star Skills Competition warm-up in Laval, February 2023. It is not a photograph of the Maple Leafs' game against Utah.
Ice Hockey

Hiller Calls Raddysh's Penalty 'Stupid' After It Costs Maple Leafs Against Utah

Toronto coach Jim Hiller did not hide behind coach-speak after a 3-2 loss to Utah, calling Darren Raddysh's third-period cross-checking penalty stupid and saying it cost his team, and Raddysh agreed.

File photo from 17 October 2022: Auston Matthews in a Toronto Maple Leafs uniform against the Arizona Coyotes. It was not taken at the Calgary game and does not show the faceoff penalty or Cowan.
Ice Hockey

Cowan Says 'I Cost Us the Game' as Matthews Disputes Hand Penalty in Leafs' 5-2 Loss

Easton Cowan blamed himself for Toronto's 5-2 loss at Calgary after a turnover and a roughing minor, while Auston Matthews questioned a delay-of-game call on a faceoff hand pass on the night he reached 800 career points.

File photo from 18 March 2023: Leon Draisaitl of the Oilers with Jaden Schwartz of the Kraken. It was not taken at the Leafs game in Edmonton.
Ice Hockey

Draisaitl Cross-Checks Matthews in the Ribs and Gets No Penalty as Leafs Win 7-2

Leon Draisaitl caught Auston Matthews with a cross-check to the ribs in his first shift on Saturday, no penalty was called, and the Leafs captain answered by scoring in a 7-2 win.

File photo: Gavin McKenna playing for Penn State against Wisconsin at the Kohl Center in Madison, completing his first collegiate hat trick. It does not show the Maple Leafs game against Buffalo. The 16:9 cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY-SA 4.0 licence.
Ice Hockey

Hiller Says Benching McKenna Was His Mistake as the Leafs Blow a 4-2 Lead

Gavin McKenna played 6:36 and sat the final 32:54 of Toronto's overtime loss to Buffalo. Coach Jim Hiller says the benching was his error, not the rookie's.

File photo from 2 February 2022: Connor McDavid skating for the Edmonton Oilers in Washington. It does not show the Utah game. The 16:9 cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY-SA 2.0 licence.
Ice Hockey

McDavid Ties Lemieux and Gretzky's Eight-Game Assists Mark With 17

Connor McDavid's five points at Utah took him to 23 in eight games. His 17 assists tie Lemieux and Gretzky for the most through eight games of a season.