Maple Leafs GM Calls 0-6 Homestand 'Unacceptable' but Backs Coach Jim Hiller
On this page6
Toronto GM John Chayka called the Maple Leafs’ winless six-game homestand unacceptable on Monday, then gave the coach responsible for it his full support. It is the classic general manager’s straddle: condemn the results, protect the hire, and buy time with a schedule that gets easier. The Leafs are 8-12-2, last in the Atlantic and nine points out of a playoff spot, and the next seven games will decide whether the backing holds.
Is Jim Hiller getting fired?
No, not on the current word from the front office. Chayka used Monday’s practice to back his first-year coach in public. “We’ve got a lot of confidence in Jim,” he said, “and Mats and I have full support behind him. And I think adversity is an opportunity to learn, an opportunity to grow.” Chayka hired Hiller in June, five months ago, after parting ways with Craig Berube, and Hiller was one of several new faces Chayka brought in hoping to get Toronto back into the playoffs after a down year. Firing him now would mean admitting the first big hire of the new regime was wrong before Christmas.
How bad is the skid?
Bad enough that the GM could not dress it up. The Leafs went without a point in a six-game homestand, were outscored 23-9, and have one win in their last nine games. They are last in the Atlantic Division and nine points behind the Florida Panthers for the final wild-card spot, 22 games into the season. The homestand ended with a 1-0 loss to Connor McDavid’s Edmonton Oilers on Saturday, a game Toronto played well and still lost, which is the cruelest kind of defeat for a team that has stopped believing its process will be rewarded.
Chayka did not pretend otherwise. “These short-term results aren’t what we expect and it’s unacceptable,” he said. “We think we hold ourselves to a higher standard and fans deserve better. The ownership gives us all the resources to go out and have success and, you know, it’s on us as a group to get the job done. But I’d say, I’m not going to try to assign blame. I’m looking for solutions.” He added that two things can be true at once: the results are not what anyone wanted, and there can still be good signs of progress.
Why does the vote of confidence sound familiar?
Because Toronto heard the same language a year ago, from the man Chayka replaced. Last November, then-GM Brad Treliving gave Craig Berube a public vote of confidence in near-identical terms, telling reporters he had all the faith in his coach, that Berube had not become a bad coach overnight, and that the way out was digging in together rather than pointing fingers. Berube was fired in May, six weeks after Treliving himself was dismissed. A vote of confidence is support in the moment, not a guarantee for the season, and everyone in Toronto knows the difference. The parallel is the reason Chayka’s backing reads as a stay of execution rather than a blank cheque.
What about the goalie and the rookie?
Chayka backed both of them too, which is the other half of the message: the problem is the group, not one man. Sergei Bobrovsky, signed in the summer as the headline move of the offseason, has struggled throughout his time in Toronto, but Chayka said he continues to believe in the veteran, calling him a process-oriented guy who has been through everything in his career and saying it is deserved and prudent to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Gavin McKenna, the 18-year-old No. 1 pick, has 13 points in 22 games, third among rookies, but just two points in his past seven games and no point in his past two. His ice time has fluctuated, from 10:38 against Minnesota to 17:22 against New Jersey, and Chayka said he has no issues with the rookie’s progress. McKenna has had regular conversations with Hiller about simplifying his game, which is the same careful handling Hiller showed when he admitted benching McKenna was his mistake in October.
What is the way out?
The schedule, for a start. All six home losses came against teams in playoff position, and starting with Tuesday’s Original Six Series game at Chicago, six of the Leafs’ next seven games are against teams currently out of playoff position. Hiller put it simply: there is pressure every game to win, and that is the pressure he is feeling. The names already being floated if it does not work, in a Sportskeeda rundown, are Bruce Cassidy, John Tortorella, David Carle, Kris Knoblauch and Patrick Roy. Cassidy is the notable one: Vegas granted permission to exactly one team last June, and Sportsnet reported it was Toronto, which hired Hiller anyway. The Flyers fans who flew a plane banner calling for Rick Tocchet’s job on Sunday are the reminder of what the pressure looks like when a fanbase stops waiting.
What happens next?
Tuesday in Chicago, then the road trip. Chayka left no clues on a timeframe, and DAZN’s report of the availability notes the same: the vote of confidence has no expiry date attached. Hiller has been here before, in a way: he spent parts of the past three seasons as coach of the Los Angeles Kings, where he went 93-58-24 and lost in the first round twice before he was fired in March. He also has a recent reminder of how fast a bench can turn: he called Darren Raddysh’s penalty stupid after Utah beat Toronto earlier this month, and Raddysh agreed with him. The coach and the GM are aligned in public. The next seven games will show whether that alignment survives contact with the standings.
Frequently asked questions
Is Jim Hiller getting fired?+
No, not on the current word from the front office. GM John Chayka used Monday's practice to back his coach in public, saying he and senior executive advisor Mats Sundin have full support behind Hiller. Chayka hired Hiller in June, five months ago, after parting ways with Craig Berube.
What did Chayka actually say about Hiller?+
He said, 'We've got a lot of confidence in Jim, and Mats and I have full support behind him. And I think adversity is an opportunity to learn, an opportunity to grow.' In the same availability he called the results unacceptable and said fans deserve better, and that he is not looking to assign blame but to find solutions.
How bad is the Maple Leafs' skid?+
They went without a point in a six-game homestand, were outscored 23-9, and have one win in their last nine games to sit at 8-12-2. They are last in the Atlantic Division and nine points behind the Florida Panthers for the final wild-card spot, 22 games into the season. The homestand ended with a 1-0 loss to Connor McDavid's Edmonton Oilers on Saturday.
Why does the vote of confidence sound familiar?+
Because Toronto heard the same language a year ago. Last November, then-GM Brad Treliving gave Craig Berube a public vote of confidence in near-identical terms, saying he had all the faith in his coach and that the way out was digging in together. Berube was fired in May, and Chayka replaced Treliving six weeks earlier. A vote of confidence is support, not a guarantee.
What did Chayka say about Sergei Bobrovsky?+
He backed the goalie too. Bobrovsky has struggled since signing in the summer, but Chayka said he continues to believe in the veteran, calling him a process-oriented guy who has been through everything in his career and saying it is deserved and prudent to give him the benefit of the doubt and let him get back in the net.
How is Gavin McKenna doing in all of this?+
The 18-year-old No. 1 pick has 13 points in 22 games, third among rookies, but just two points in his past seven games and no point in his past two. His ice time has fluctuated, from 10:38 against Minnesota to 17:22 against New Jersey, and Chayka said he has no issues with the rookie's progress and that McKenna has regular conversations with Hiller about simplifying his game.
What is the way out of the skid?+
The schedule helps. All six home losses came against teams in playoff position, and starting with Tuesday's game at Chicago, six of the Leafs' next seven games are against teams currently out of playoff position. Hiller put it simply: there is pressure every game to win, and that is the pressure he is feeling.
Who would replace Hiller if the skid continues?+
Nobody has been named, and Chayka gave no timeframe. The names already being floated, in a Sportskeeda rundown of candidates, are Bruce Cassidy, John Tortorella, David Carle, Kris Knoblauch and Patrick Roy. Cassidy is the notable one: Vegas granted permission to exactly one team last June, and Sportsnet reported it was Toronto, which hired Hiller anyway.
Sources
- TSN: Maple Leafs GM Chayka calls recent skid 'unacceptable,' but backs Hiller as coach (the Monday availability, the quotes, the 8-12-2 record, the Berube history)
- NHL.com: Maple Leafs won't be defined by 0-6-0 homestand, Chayka says (the Chicago trip, the McKenna detail, the Matthews line, the draft lottery)
- Sportskeeda: Maple Leafs head coach candidates (the 23-9 homestand margin, the eight losses in nine, the five names being floated)
- Sportsnet: Treliving endorses Berube but offers few solutions for 'vanilla' Maple Leafs (the November vote of confidence for Berube in near-identical terms)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 98-0 — Draft a 12-player all-time NHL roster and chase a perfect 98-0 — 82 regular-season wins plus a swept Cup.
- Explore all our games →
Related ice hockey guides
View all →
Hiller Says Benching McKenna Was His Mistake as the Leafs Blow a 4-2 Lead
Gavin McKenna played 6:36 and sat the final 32:54 of Toronto's overtime loss to Buffalo. Coach Jim Hiller says the benching was his error, not the rookie's.
Hiller Calls Raddysh's Penalty 'Stupid' After It Costs Maple Leafs Against Utah
Toronto coach Jim Hiller did not hide behind coach-speak after a 3-2 loss to Utah, calling Darren Raddysh's third-period cross-checking penalty stupid and saying it cost his team, and Raddysh agreed.
Cowan Says 'I Cost Us the Game' as Matthews Disputes Hand Penalty in Leafs' 5-2 Loss
Easton Cowan blamed himself for Toronto's 5-2 loss at Calgary after a turnover and a roughing minor, while Auston Matthews questioned a delay-of-game call on a faceoff hand pass on the night he reached 800 career points.
Zadorov Is Scratched for Discipline, Then His Agent Teases Toronto
Marco Sturm made Nikita Zadorov a healthy scratch on Saturday over his penalty discipline. Hours later his agent told a fan on X that Toronto would not treat him this way.
Ekman-Larsson Leaves on a Lauzon Hit With No Penalty, Then Practices a Day Later
Oliver Ekman-Larsson left Toronto's loss in Vegas late on a Jeremy Lauzon hit that drew no penalty. He was back on the practice ice on Friday.
Tavares' Tying Goal Wiped Out on Review as Leafs Lose 1-0 to Oilers
John Tavares had a tying goal wiped out for a high stick after a four-minute review as Toronto lost 1-0 to Edmonton and finished a winless homestand.