SportsMonkie.com
NFL

Rutgers Stuns Penn State 25-24 on a Lateral Touchdown and Walk-Off Two-Pointer

By SportsMonkie NFL Desk Updated November 21, 2026
File photo from 5 August 2014: Beaver Stadium from the east at Penn State University. It does not show the Rutgers game.
Image: Beaver Stadium Penn State PA1 by Acroterion · via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Share this guide
On this page7
  1. 01How did Rutgers score on the final play?
  2. 02Who caught the winning two-point conversion?
  3. 03What was the pass interference call that set it up?
  4. 04Was there a whistle before the lateral?
  5. 05How big an upset was it?
  6. 06What does it mean for Penn State?
  7. 07What happens next?

Rutgers beat Penn State 25-24 at Beaver Stadium on Saturday, and the ending had everything: a lateral on the final play, a walk-off two-point conversion, a disputed flag, and a coach arguing about a whistle that may never have blown. The Scarlet Knights were 25.5-point underdogs, 2-8, and had lost four straight by a combined 87 points. They left State College with their first win over Penn State since 1988.

How did Rutgers score on the final play?

With no time left and the ball at the Penn State 2, quarterback AJ Surace threw a swing pass out wide to running back Antwan Raymond. Raymond was stopped near the goal line, and as defenders swarmed him he pitched the ball to Ben Black III, who ran it into the end zone. The replay official reviewed whether Raymond had broken the plane and upheld the touchdown, cutting Penn State’s lead to 24-23. It was the kind of play that looks broken until it works, and Rutgers had already survived one ending before it: on fourth-and-eight with 10 seconds left, Surace’s pass to Black in the end zone fell incomplete, and the game looked over until the flag came out.

Who caught the winning two-point conversion?

Clay Thevenin, wide open in the flat. Rutgers decided to end the game right there rather than settle for overtime, and Surace dropped back, looked right and found Thevenin untouched for the score. The play was a much cleaner finish than the touchdown, with Penn State’s defense washed out of the side and only defensive end Alexander McPherson left to chase Thevenin. One outlet initially named David Gilley as the receiver, but the official play-by-play, Sports Illustrated and On3 all name Thevenin, and this article goes with the majority record. Auburn stunned No. 1 Georgia on a walk-off kick earlier in the day, so Saturday was already a day for the unexpected before Rutgers added the wildest finish of the season.

What was the pass interference call that set it up?

A flag on a ball that looked uncatchable. On fourth-and-eight with 10 seconds remaining, Surace threw for Black in the end zone and the pass fell incomplete. Officials called defensive pass interference on Penn State, giving Rutgers one more down, and the Scarlet Knights scored on the next sequence. Sports Illustrated reported that the officials named the wrong player on the penalty, cornerback Audavion Collins, who was in coverage on the far side of the field, while the closest defender to the pass was cornerback Daryus Dixson and the ball appeared to sail out of the end zone. The call was the break Rutgers needed, and Penn State had no challenge left to spend on it. Georgia beat Alabama in October after a no-call and fans throwing objects, so the Big Ten is not the only conference where one flag, or the absence of one, has decided a game this season.

Was there a whistle before the lateral?

Penn State coach Matt Campbell thinks there might have been one, and his own tackler disagrees. Campbell argued with the officials that Raymond’s forward progress had been stopped before the pitch to Black, and said after the game that he thought the officials might have blown a whistle, ending the play. “They said they were going to review it, and obviously they did, and obviously that is the call,” Campbell said. “I think the one thing we thought maybe was there a whistle? It felt like that.” Linebacker Kooper Ebel, who was on Raymond on the play, said he did not hear a whistle to stop it. “I wish I would have knocked it down,” Ebel said of the lateral, “not even given him a chance to lateral it.” The touchdown stood, and the argument will follow Penn State into the offseason whether the whistle existed or not. Oregon’s Dan Lanning decided a punch that drew no flag would draw no punishment from him either, which is the other end of the discipline spectrum from a game decided by a flag and a review.

How big an upset was it?

As big as the line suggested. Rutgers entered as a 25.5-point underdog, per FanDuel Sportsbook, gained nine yards of offense in the first quarter, fell behind 16-0 on a 56-yard Cam Wallace touchdown run and a safety, and trailed 24-10 with under 11 minutes left in the fourth quarter. Then the Scarlet Knights put together a 19-play, 75-yard drive that ate up nearly 10 minutes and ended with Raymond’s 13-yard touchdown run, got the ball back with 3:28 left, and marched 67 yards in 11 plays for the finish. Raymond ran for 101 yards with two touchdowns, Surace threw for 178 yards, and Rutgers outscored Penn State 15-0 in the fourth quarter. Tennessee fans threw golf balls and mustard at Lane Kiffin again later on Saturday, so the day belonged to the home crowds and the underdogs in equal measure.

What does it mean for Penn State?

It is the third inexplicable finish of the season for a team in its first year under Campbell. Penn State blew a 17-point lead at Wisconsin, nearly blew a 22-point lead at Washington, and on Saturday gave up 16- and 14-point leads at home to a 2-8 team, gaining 26 yards and one first down on its final two series. “You can’t leave it to chance,” Campbell said, and the message in the locker room was about mentality as much as tactics. Defensive end Ikenna Ezeogu said the team’s frame of mind was wrong from the start of the week. “I feel like the mentality was a little wrong at the beginning of the game, not really the beginning of the game, throughout the whole week,” he said. Michigan’s Zack Marshall apologized for leaked texts criticizing his coordinator earlier in the season, which is the other way a program’s week can go sideways before kickoff. Penn State had won three straight after losing its first four Big Ten games, and the momentum is gone.

What happens next?

Both teams close the regular season on Saturday, November 28. Rutgers hosts Michigan State, and Penn State visits Maryland, with kickoff scheduled for 3:30 p.m. ET on FS1. Rutgers will try to carry the strangest win of its season into a finale that suddenly matters for morale, and Penn State will try to avoid ending Campbell’s first season with a loss to a team it had beaten 18 straight times. The final play will be replayed all week, and the whistle question will be argued just as long, but the record now reads Rutgers 25, Penn State 24, and nothing in the review changed that.

Share this article

Frequently asked questions

How did Rutgers score the winning touchdown?+

With no time left, quarterback AJ Surace threw a swing pass to running back Antwan Raymond, who was stopped near the goal line and pitched the ball to Ben Black III. Black ran it into the end zone as time expired. The replay official reviewed whether Raymond had broken the plane and upheld the touchdown.

Who caught the two-point conversion?+

Clay Thevenin. Surace dropped back, looked to the flat and found Thevenin wide open for the winner. One outlet initially named David Gilley, but the official play-by-play, Sports Illustrated and On3 all name Thevenin. Rutgers went for two instead of settling for overtime.

What was the pass interference call that set it up?+

On fourth-and-eight with 10 seconds left, Surace's pass to Black in the end zone fell incomplete, but officials flagged Penn State for defensive pass interference and gave Rutgers one more down. Sports Illustrated reported the officials named the wrong player, cornerback Audavion Collins, who was in coverage on the far side, while the closest defender to the pass was Daryus Dixson and the ball appeared uncatchable.

Was there a whistle before the lateral?+

Penn State coach Matt Campbell argued that Raymond's forward progress may have been stopped and that the officials might have blown a whistle before the pitch. Linebacker Kooper Ebel, who was on Raymond on the play, said he did not hear a whistle. The touchdown stood after a replay review.

How long was Rutgers' losing streak to Penn State?+

Eighteen games. Rutgers had not beaten Penn State since 1988, when former Penn State assistant Dick Anderson was the Scarlet Knights' head coach. The win was Rutgers' first against the Nittany Lions in 38 years.

How big an upset was it?+

Rutgers entered as a 25.5-point underdog, per FanDuel Sportsbook, with a 2-8 record and four straight losses by a combined 87 points. The Scarlet Knights gained nine yards of offense in the first quarter, trailed 16-0 and then 24-10 with under 11 minutes left, and outscored Penn State 15-0 in the fourth quarter.

What does it mean for Penn State?+

It is the third inexplicable finish of the season for first-year coach Matt Campbell's team, which also blew a 17-point lead at Wisconsin and nearly blew a 22-point lead at Washington. Penn State gained 26 yards and one first down on its final two series, and Campbell said afterward that the team keeps leaving results to chance.

What happens next for both teams?+

Both teams close the regular season on Saturday, November 28. Rutgers hosts Michigan State, and Penn State visits Maryland, with kickoff scheduled for 3:30 p.m. ET on FS1.

Sources

Play & tools

Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.

  • Play 17-0 — Draft nine and chase a flawless NFL regular season — the perfect 17-0 run, no playoffs.
  • Play 20-0 — Draft nine and chase a perfect NFL season — regular season and playoffs, undefeated.
  • Play 16-0 — Draft nine and chase a perfect 16-0 — the classic 16-game NFL regular season, no playoffs.
  • Play Flawless Six — Draft five players and a head coach, then chase a perfect NFL season with the right chemistry.
  • Play Guess the NFL Player — A new mystery NFL player every day. Eight guesses, with a clue on each — plus free unlimited mode.
  • Play NFL Wordle — A Wordle for football — guess the daily NFL player in eight tries, with green-amber-grey feedback on every clue.
  • Play NFL Connections — Sort sixteen football tiles into four hidden groups of four. A new daily puzzle, four mistakes allowed, plus unlimited mode.
  • Explore all our games →

Related nfl guides

View all →