Michigan-Michigan State Brawl Ejects Six as Rivalry Boils Over at Yost
On this page6
No. 1 Michigan beat No. 9 Michigan State 5-1 on Friday, and nobody will remember the score. The game at Yost Ice Arena ended in a third-period brawl that saw six players disqualified, three from each team, and more than 100 penalty minutes handed out. All six are automatically suspended for Saturday night’s rematch in East Lansing, and the Big Ten or the NCAA could still add more discipline.
What started the brawl?
One hit, in front of the wrong bench. Michigan State defenceman Sean Barnhill, a New York Rangers prospect, delivered a hit from behind on Michigan forward Nick Moldenhauer, a Toronto Maple Leafs draft pick, just after the seven-minute mark of the third period, right in front of the Michigan bench. The hit sparked a fight on the ice that looked like it might settle, and then it got worse. Michigan State captain Patrick Geary got into it with several Wolverines near the Michigan bench, including goaltender Jack Ivankovic, and a second, longer melee broke out across the ice. “Benches are clearing, guys are on the ice wrestling each other, what is going on? Chaos,” the announcer said as players piled in. It is the kind of scene college hockey rarely sees, and it came in the fiercest rivalry in the college game, with the top-ranked Wolverines hosting the ninth-ranked Spartans in the first game of a home-and-home weekend.
Who was ejected?
Six players, three from each side, all with fighting majors and game disqualifications. Michigan lost forwards Michael Hage and Nic Sima and defenceman Drew Schock. Michigan State lost Barnhill, forward Shane Vansaghi and defenceman Matthew Lahey. Barnhill took 17 penalty minutes on the play alone: a minor for boarding, a five-minute fighting major and the disqualification. The names matter because almost all of them are NHL property: Hage belongs to Montreal, Schock to Anaheim, Vansaghi to Philadelphia, Lahey to Toronto, and Barnhill to the Rangers. Even 2027 top draft prospect Landon DuPont was in the middle of it, mixing it up with players several years older than him. Fighting in the NHL is a different world, where a veteran can call out a rookie for dropping the gloves, but in the NCAA a fighting major means an automatic disqualification, and that is what turned a brawl into six suspensions.
Why do all six miss the rematch?
Because the punishment is automatic. A game disqualification in NCAA hockey carries a one-game suspension, so the six ejected players are barred from Saturday night’s rematch in East Lansing without anyone having to rule on it. Michigan loses Hage, who had 26 points in 11 games heading into the match, along with Sima and Schock. Michigan State loses Barnhill, Vansaghi and Lahey. Both coaches will have to juggle their lines on short notice, and the rematch now has a different edge: the teams meet again less than 24 hours after a brawl, with three players a side already sitting out. The NHL has its own version of this arithmetic, where a star can go from a controversial penalty to a shootout winner in the same night, but in college hockey the rulebook does the deciding, and it decided all six are out.
What else happened in the melee?
Plenty that the officials are still sorting through. Barnhill, Vansaghi and Lahey left the penalty box to rejoin the fighting, while Michigan’s Adam Valentini and Aidan Park left their bench, according to Daily Faceoff. After reviewing the video, no other Spartans left their bench. Ivankovic left his crease to get involved, and a Michigan State player shoved him, which Michigan coach Brandon Naurato mentioned after the game. Daily Faceoff also reported that Michigan forward Jack Nesbitt punched Geary while the Michigan State captain was lying on the ice, and somehow went unpenalised. Geary received a game misconduct and Michigan captain Garrett Schifsky a 10-minute misconduct, but neither was disqualified. The league has handed out fines for stick incidents this week too, and the standard for what counts as a punishable act is under scrutiny across the sport.
What did the coaches say?
Neither coach condemned his own players. Michigan State coach Adam Nightingale said Barnhill took a two-minute penalty and the Wolverines did not like it. “You stick up for your teammate and we’re going to stick up for our teammates,” he said, according to the Lansing State Journal. “The refs did a great job of handling that.” Naurato was proud of his players for defending each other, and he put it bluntly: “Their guy jumped the bench and came over towards ours. Anyone comes around Jack it’s not good.” Michigan forward Jack Nesbitt backed him up: “It’s one of the biggest rivalries in sports so there’s gonna be a lot of that. If anyone goes after (Ivankovic) then it’s game on.”
What happens next?
The rematch, on Saturday night in East Lansing, with six players already out and both teams short-handed. The one-game bans are automatic, but the Big Ten or the NCAA can still hand out supplemental discipline on top, and Daily Faceoff said it would not be a shock if either body stepped in. The league has the video of the whole sequence, including players leaving the penalty box and the bench, and a punch on a player lying on the ice that went unpenalised. The rivalry resumes in less than a day, and the question is whether the rematch settles it or starts it again.
Frequently asked questions
What was the score in the Michigan vs Michigan State game?+
Michigan won 5-1 at Yost Ice Arena in Ann Arbor on Friday, in the first game of a home-and-home weekend series between the No. 1 Wolverines and the No. 9 Spartans. The brawl broke out in the third period with Michigan already running away with the game, and it overshadowed a 37-save performance from Michigan goaltender Jack Ivankovic.
What started the brawl?+
Michigan State defenceman Sean Barnhill, a New York Rangers prospect, delivered a hit from behind on Michigan forward Nick Moldenhauer, a Toronto Maple Leafs draft pick, just after the seven-minute mark of the third period, right in front of the Michigan bench. The hit sparked a fight on the ice, and after a brief pause a second, longer melee broke out near the Michigan bench.
Which six players were ejected?+
Three from each team received fighting majors and game disqualifications. Michigan lost forwards Michael Hage and Nic Sima and defenceman Drew Schock, while Michigan State lost Barnhill, forward Shane Vansaghi and defenceman Matthew Lahey. Barnhill took 17 penalty minutes on the play: a minor for boarding, a five-minute fighting major and the disqualification.
Why are all six suspended for the rematch?+
A game disqualification in NCAA hockey carries an automatic one-game suspension, so all six are barred from Saturday night's rematch in East Lansing without anyone having to rule on it. The two teams meet again at Michigan State, and both coaches will have to juggle their lines on short notice.
Was anyone else punished?+
Michigan State captain Patrick Geary received a game misconduct and Michigan captain Garrett Schifsky a 10-minute misconduct, but neither was disqualified, so neither is automatically suspended. Daily Faceoff reported that Michigan forward Jack Nesbitt punched Geary while the Michigan State captain was lying on the ice, and somehow went unpenalised.
How did the benches and the goalies get involved?+
Barnhill, Vansaghi and Lahey left the penalty box to rejoin the fighting, while Michigan's Adam Valentini and Aidan Park left their bench, according to Daily Faceoff. Michigan goaltender Jack Ivankovic left his crease to get involved, and a Michigan State player shoved him, which Michigan coach Brandon Naurato mentioned after the game.
What did the coaches say about it?+
Michigan State coach Adam Nightingale said Barnhill took a two-minute penalty and the Wolverines did not like it, adding that players stick up for their teammates and that the referees did a great job handling it. Michigan coach Brandon Naurato said he was proud of his players for defending each other, and that anyone who comes around Ivankovic will find it is game on.
Could there be more discipline coming?+
Yes. The one-game bans are automatic, but the Big Ten or the NCAA can still hand out supplemental discipline on top, and Daily Faceoff said it would not be a shock if either body stepped in. The league and the NCAA have the video of the whole sequence, including players leaving the penalty box and the bench.
Sources
- New York Post: Insane college hockey brawl between Michigan-Michigan State breaks out (the 5-1 score, the six ejections, 116 penalty minutes, the Barnhill hit, the coaches' quotes, the one-game suspensions)
- Daily Faceoff: Brawl breaks out during Michigan, Michigan State NCAA hockey game (the 126 penalty minutes from the incident, the six names and their NHL clubs, the penalty-box and bench exits, the Nesbitt punch, the supplemental discipline possibility)
- Spartans Wire (USA Today): At least six suspended between Michigan State, Michigan hockey (the 5-1 result, the fighting majors and game disqualifications, the automatic one-game suspension, the possibility of further discipline)
- Yardbarker: Things are heating up in Michigan, Michael Hage ejected during a brawl (the 5-1 win, the six suspensions, Hage's 26 points in 11 games, the video of the brawl)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 98-0 — Draft a 12-player all-time NHL roster and chase a perfect 98-0 — 82 regular-season wins plus a swept Cup.
- Explore all our games →
Related ice hockey guides
View all →
Arizona State Parts Ways With Greg Powers and Hires Dave Hakstol as the Mayich Review Continues
Greg Powers is out at Arizona State and Dave Hakstol is in, while the independent review of Matthew Mayich's August collapse is still running.
Michigan Stuns No. 2 UConn 77-66 as Geno Auriemma Blames Himself for the Loss
No. 5 Michigan beat No. 2 UConn 77-66 for the highest-ranked win in program history, ending the Huskies' 39-game regular-season streak as Geno Auriemma took the blame.
Michigan's Zack Marshall Apologizes for Leaked Texts Criticizing Coordinator Jason Beck
Michigan tight end Zack Marshall apologized after group-chat texts criticizing offensive coordinator Jason Beck and the Wolverines' scheme leaked online.
Bowman Ejected for Elbow on Poitras as Bruins Win Shootout Over Golden Knights
Vegas forward Braeden Bowman was ejected for elbowing Matthew Poitras in Boston's 3-2 shootout win, and Poitras returned to the bench in a full shield but took no further shift.
Devils Bench Hellebuyck for His Winnipeg Return Over 'Expected Win Probability'
The Devils will not start Connor Hellebuyck in Winnipeg on Tuesday, with GM Sunny Mehta citing a potential reduction in expected win probability.
Both Tkachuk Brothers Are Ejected as Bruins-Panthers Descends Into 126 Penalty Minutes
Brady and Matthew Tkachuk both drew 10-minute misconducts three minutes apart in the third period of the Bruins' 4-1 win over the Panthers, capping a game with 126 penalty minutes.