Heineman Escapes Further Discipline After Knee-on-Knee Ejection of Howard
On this page8
- 01What happened on the hit?
- 02What penalty did Heineman receive?
- 03How serious is Howard’s injury?
- 04What did the coaches say about the call?
- 05Will Heineman be suspended?
- 06Update, October 31: Howard out Sunday at the Rangers, but the news is better than feared
- 07Update, November 2: No hearing, no further discipline for Heineman
- 08What happens next?
Emil Heineman’s afternoon lasted barely two minutes. The New York Islanders winger was ejected early in Saturday’s game against Edmonton for a knee-on-knee hit on Oilers winger Isaac Howard, who stayed down in pain and left without putting weight on his left leg. Officials assessed a five-minute major for kneeing and a game misconduct after video review, Edmonton killed the penalty, won 4-0, and then delivered the only good news of the day: the first report on Howard was favorable, even though he figures to miss Sunday’s game at the Rangers. The hit itself is not in dispute. The punishment still to come is.
What happened on the hit?
A knee meeting a knee, at speed, along the boards. Just over two minutes into the first period, Heineman’s outstretched left knee made contact with Howard’s knee in the neutral zone. Howard remained on the ice in pain, was visited by a trainer, and did not put any weight on his left leg as he was helped off to the bench and down the tunnel. He did not return, and he was limping slightly as he walked out of the visiting locker room after the game. The sequence is the nightmare version of a common hockey collision: two players arriving at the same spot, one of them leading with a joint that has no padding for that kind of contact. It is also the kind of play the league has spent years trying to coach out of the game, which is why the officials did not let the original call stand on its own.
What penalty did Heineman receive?
The maximum the officials could give on the spot. They assessed a five-minute major for kneeing, reviewed the play on video, and upheld the call with a game misconduct. Heineman threw his stick as he exited, which told its own story about how he felt about the ruling. Edmonton did not score on the five-minute power play: goaltender Ilya Sorokin made three saves as the Islanders killed the entire penalty, so the major cost New York a player but not a goal. That detail matters for the game, and it does not matter at all for the discipline case, which turns on the hit and the injury rather than the score. The same week already produced a boarding ejection with a two-game suspension attached, when Hayden Hodgson was ejected for boarding Brandt Clarke and Clarke left with an upper-body injury, and the Islanders know that script well: their own captain was on the receiving end of it.
How serious is Howard’s injury?
Bad enough to end his game, not as bad as it first looked. Edmonton’s coach said after the 4-0 win that the club does not think the injury is as serious as it looked, and that Howard would get a recovery day before any further medical steps. That is a deliberately careful form of good news: favorable is not the same as cleared, and the same report says Howard figures to be out for Sunday’s game at the Rangers. His teammate Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, who scored twice in the win, put the room’s feeling plainly, saying it is tough to see a player who has been playing well and starting to get swagger and confidence go down like that. Howard is 22 and fighting for a bigger role on Edmonton’s fourth line after arriving from Tampa Bay in exchange for prospect Sam O’Reilly, so a missed game is also a missed chance to hold that spot.
What did the coaches say about the call?
They disagreed, which is the point of the review system. Edmonton’s coach said there was no doubt about the decision, while the Islanders’ coach expressed surprise that it was ruled a major penalty. Nugent-Hopkins sided with the officials, saying they did a good job going back and figuring out that it was a major, and adding that he was sure the Department of Player Safety would look at it. That is the honest shape of a kneeing debate: one bench sees a dangerous lead with the knee, the other sees a collision that did not deserve five minutes and an ejection, and the video review is supposed to settle it. On Saturday it settled in Edmonton’s favor, and the review upholding the major is the strongest signal yet about what Player Safety will do next. Boarding cases have already set the tone this month, with Anthony Mantha’s boarding major knocking out Ottawa’s Nikolas Matinpalo, and a hit that injures an opponent rarely ends with the game misconduct alone.
Will Heineman be suspended?
No, and that answer arrived on Monday. The Hockey News reports Heineman will not have a hearing with the NHL Department of Player Safety, which closes the discipline file with the ejection as the whole punishment. A major for kneeing carries an automatic game misconduct, and the department’s usual next step for a hit that injures an opponent is a hearing, a fine, or a suspension, but none of those will follow here. The favorable medical report on Howard plainly helped: a hit that ends a game but not a season reads differently from one that costs a player months, and the department evidently judged the five-minute major and the ejection to be enough. Heineman’s profile will factor into that call: he is a 24-year-old Swedish winger playing a physical bottom-six role at 6-foot-2 and 198 pounds, with two goals and four assists in 13 games before Saturday, and he arrived in New York from Montreal in the Noah Dobson trade. None of that is an excuse, and none of it is an aggravating factor on its own. What matters is the video: an outstretched knee, contact in the neutral zone, and an opponent who could not put weight on his leg. The comparison cases from this season show how much the label decides the punishment, from the Nazar head-check ban to the Rodrigues stick-jab fine, and Heineman’s case now joins that ledger.
Update, October 31: Howard out Sunday at the Rangers, but the news is better than feared
The worst-case reading of Saturday’s hit is now off the table, and the best available outcome is a week of waiting instead of a month of it. Edmonton coach Mike Babcock told the media after the game that Isaac Howard seems to have avoided serious injury from Emil Heineman’s knee-on-knee hit, Pro Hockey Rumors reports, with the Associated Press among the outlets carrying the postgame update. Howard will not play Sunday at Madison Square Garden against the Rangers, but there is optimism for a return next week, which is a very different prognosis from the one the hit suggested when Howard was helped off without weight on his left leg after just 30 seconds of ice time.
In Howard’s place on Sunday, Babcock will choose between depth forwards Filip Hallander and Max Jones. Neither replaces what Howard was supposed to be for Edmonton: a 22-year-old former Tampa Bay first-rounder, one of the team’s brightest young talents, with three points in 12 games, mostly from the fourth line with time on the second power-play unit. But a one-game absence with a return next week is a survivable loss for a team that reached 10 wins with Saturday’s 4-0 victory. The alternative, a knee injury measured in months, would have changed Edmonton’s season.
What has not changed is the other half of the file. No Department of Player Safety decision on Heineman had been announced as of Saturday evening, despite the expectation of a review that TSN, Pro Hockey Rumors and others noted after the game. The Islanders have four days off before hosting Carolina on November 5, which gives the department time to hold a hearing before Heineman’s team plays again. The favorable medical report helps Howard; it does not necessarily help Heineman, since the department judges the act as well as the outcome, and the video still shows an outstretched knee in the neutral zone. Sunday will confirm Howard’s absence. The coming week will decide whether Heineman’s exit on Saturday was the whole punishment or only the start of it.
Update, November 2: No hearing, no further discipline for Heineman
The file is closed, and Heineman is free to play Thursday. The Hockey News reports the Islanders forward will not have a hearing with the NHL Department of Player Safety after the Halloween ejection, which means the five-minute major and game misconduct from Saturday stand as the entire punishment. The report notes the Islanders struggled through a penalty-filled 4-0 loss down a forward, taking four additional minor penalties on top of the major, with the Oilers scoring only once on the power play. Islanders coach Peter DeBoer summed up the night bluntly, saying the team was a day late and a dollar short.
The decision also settles the lineup question for Thursday’s game against Carolina at UBS Arena. The Islanders had been carrying only 12 healthy forwards, which made a suspension a real roster problem, and they now get Heineman back without having to reach for a minor-league call-up. For Howard, the news is unchanged and still encouraging: out Sunday at the Rangers, with optimism for a return next week. The hit cost Heineman two minutes of one game and a thrown stick. It will not cost him anything more.
What happens next?
Two schedules, both clearer than they were on Saturday. Edmonton goes to Madison Square Garden on Sunday to face the Rangers without Howard, who is out with optimism for a return next week, before finishing its three-game road trip in New Jersey on Tuesday. The Islanders host Carolina on November 5 with Heineman available, after four days off that turned out to be a break rather than a wait for a hearing. The favorable early report on Howard is the best outcome available from a bad play, and the discipline decision is the second-best: a recovery day, then a medical decision, then a return date for Howard, and a clean slate for Heineman. He threw his stick on the way out on Saturday. The league has now decided that exit was the whole punishment.
Frequently asked questions
What happened on the Heineman hit?+
Just over two minutes into the first period, Heineman's outstretched left knee made contact with Howard's knee along the boards in the neutral zone. Howard remained on the ice in pain, was visited by a trainer, and did not put any weight on his left leg as he was helped off to the bench and down the tunnel. He did not return to the game, and was limping slightly as he left the visiting locker room afterwards.
What penalty did Heineman receive?+
A five-minute major for kneeing and a game misconduct, after officials reviewed the play on video and upheld the call. Heineman threw his stick as he exited the ice. Edmonton killed off the entire five-minute power play, with goaltender Ilya Sorokin making three saves during the kill, so the major did not cost the Islanders a goal even though it cost them a player.
How serious is Howard's injury?+
Serious enough to end his afternoon, but the first report was encouraging. Edmonton's coach said after the 4-0 win that the club does not think the injury is as serious as it looked, and that Howard would get a recovery day before any further medical steps. The same report says Howard figures to be out for Sunday's game at the Rangers, so the absence is measured in days at least, not hours.
What did the two coaches say about the call?+
Edmonton's coach said there was no doubt about the decision, while the Islanders' coach expressed surprise that it was ruled a major penalty. That split is the usual shape of a kneeing debate: one bench sees a dangerous lead with the knee, the other sees a collision that did not deserve five minutes and an ejection. The video review siding with the major is what the Department of Player Safety will weigh next.
Will Heineman be suspended?+
No. The Hockey News reports Heineman will not have a hearing with the NHL Department of Player Safety after the Halloween ejection, which means no fine and no suspension follows the five-minute major and game misconduct he already served. Edmonton's Ryan Nugent-Hopkins had said after the game that he was sure Player Safety would look at it, and the department did, but its answer was that the on-ice punishment was enough.
Who are Heineman and Howard?+
Heineman is a 24-year-old Swedish winger in his first season with the Islanders after arriving from Montreal in the Noah Dobson trade, playing a physical bottom-six role at 6-foot-2 and 198 pounds, with two goals and four assists in 13 games before Saturday. Howard is a 22-year-old Oilers winger who arrived from Tampa Bay in exchange for prospect Sam O'Reilly and has been fighting for a bigger role on the fourth line.
How does this compare to other discipline cases this season?+
It sits at the serious end of the scale because the opponent was injured and the major survived review. By contrast, Chicago's Frank Nazar received a two-game ban for a head check on Islanders captain Bo Horvat, covered in [the Nazar suspension story](/nazar-match-penalty-horvat-hit-islanders/), while New Jersey's Evan Rodrigues received only the maximum $5,000 fine for a stick jab, covered in [the Rodrigues fine story](/rodrigues-fined-5000-rossi-spear-downgraded/). The label and the injury decide the punishment.
What happens next for both teams?+
Edmonton goes to Madison Square Garden on Sunday to face the Rangers, likely without Howard, before finishing its three-game road trip in New Jersey. The Islanders have four days off after the Oilers game and next host Carolina on November 5. For Heineman, the wait is for Player Safety: a hearing, a fine, a suspension, or no further action will set the cost of two minutes that changed his team's afternoon.
Sources
- AP via theScore: Islanders' Heineman ejected for knee-on-knee hit on Oilers' Howard (the ejection, the five-minute major and game misconduct, Howard helped off without weight on his left leg, Sorokin's three saves on the kill)
- AP via TSN: Islanders' Heineman ejected for a knee-on-knee hit that injured Oilers' Howard (the favorable early medical report, Howard likely out Sunday at the Rangers, both coaches' reactions, Nugent-Hopkins on Player Safety, the 4-0 final)
- Daily Faceoff via BVM Sports: Islanders' Emil Heineman ejected after hit on Oilers' Isaac Howard (the 2:22 first-period timing, the neutral-zone boards location, Heineman's season line of two goals and four assists in 13 games)
- House of Hockey: Major suspension potentially incoming after terrible knee-on-knee hit (the Rule 50 kneeing definition, the automatic game misconduct on a major, Howard's Tampa Bay background, the Player Safety outlook)
- Pro Hockey Rumors: West notes (Babcock on Howard avoiding serious injury, Howard out Sunday at the Rangers, Hallander or Jones to replace him, optimism for a return next week)
- The Hockey News: Islanders forward won't have hearing with NHL Player Safety after Halloween ejection (the no-hearing decision, the four additional minors, DeBoer's day-late quote, Thursday against Carolina)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 98-0 — Draft a 12-player all-time NHL roster and chase a perfect 98-0 — 82 regular-season wins plus a swept Cup.
- Explore all our games →
Related ice hockey guides
View all →
Podkolzin Ejected for 'One-Man Fight' After Defending McDavid
Vasily Podkolzin was ejected for a 'one-man fight' after defending Connor McDavid against Anaheim, the only player penalised for fighting as the Ducks scored on the power play.
Oilers Place Zach Hyman on Injured Reserve With Stiff Neck After Englund Hit
The Edmonton Oilers placed Zach Hyman on injured reserve with a stiff neck on Wednesday, ruling him out against Calgary, after he was hit into the boards by Detroit's Andreas Englund on Monday.
Oilers Say the Viral Rogers Place Ejection Had Nothing to Do With an Alberta Flag
A viral video claimed an Oilers fan was ejected for waving an Alberta flag. The Oilers say he was removed for disruptive conduct and language, not the flag.
Varlamov Starts After 676 Days and Two Knee Replacements in Islanders' 5-2 Loss
Semyon Varlamov made his first NHL start in 676 days at Madison Square Garden after two partial knee replacements, believed to be a first for an NHL goaltender.
Devon Levi's 'Gladiator' Ritual Earns a Russell Crowe Shoutout After First Shutout
Devon Levi stopped all 19 shots for his first NHL shutout, then Russell Crowe praised the 'Gladiator' hand-on-ice ritual behind it: 'Strength and Honour young man.'
Tavares' Tying Goal Wiped Out on Review as Leafs Lose 1-0 to Oilers
John Tavares had a tying goal wiped out for a high stick after a four-minute review as Toronto lost 1-0 to Edmonton and finished a winless homestand.