Morgan Gibbs-White Blasts VAR Over-reliance After Forest's Ipswich Draw
On this page5
TL;DR: Nottingham Forest captain Morgan Gibbs-White questioned VAR over-reliance after Friday’s 1-1 draw at Ipswich, asking why the referee needed technology to spot Issa Diop’s foul on James McAtee when the officials were standing right there. Diop got a yellow after a monitor review, Gibbs-White said the yellow was probably right but the process was wrong, and manager Oliver Glasner disagreed on the punishment, calling it a clear red card.
Forest ended a run of three straight defeats with a 1-1 draw at Ipswich on Friday, but the point came with a VAR flashpoint that split the club’s own captain and manager. Neco Williams fired Forest into a deserved 13th-minute lead, Julio Enciso cancelled it out before the break after a Nikola Milenkovic error, and then the officials took centre stage.
What happened at Portman Road?
In the 49th minute, Issa Diop wiped out James McAtee as the Forest man raced through on goal. Referee Thomas Bramall waved play on despite the whole ground sensing a foul, then VAR advised a review for denying a clear goalscoring opportunity and Bramall went to the pitchside monitor. His announcement to the crowd was precise: a foul by Ipswich’s No.6, but because McAtee knocked the ball to the right side of the goal, the decision was a direct free kick and a yellow card. It was the kind of marginal DOGSO call that has split verdicts all season, and it split this match’s two dugouts too.
What did Gibbs-White actually say?
He went after the process, not the punishment. “My only question is why does that have to go to VAR when the referee and linesman are standing there? That shouldn’t be going to VAR; they should be giving that,” the Forest captain told Sky Sports. “There needs to be some ownership on the pitch for me; the referee and linesman can see that.” He was careful to add the caveat that matters: “It is what is, that’s not the reason we didn’t win the game. We have to own the chances we’ve missed.” For a captain to volunteer that sentence on the night his team dropped points is the honest part of the quote, and the part that will age best.
Why did his manager disagree with him?
Because Oliver Glasner saw a red card, full stop. “It felt during the game it’s a clear red card. I think it was the wrong decision,” the Forest boss said. That leaves the club’s two senior figures on opposite sides of the same incident: the captain defending the yellow while attacking the VAR intervention, the manager wanting the sending-off and calling the outcome wrong. It is a disagreement that will fuel Forest’s ongoing sense of grievance without resolving anything, because both men are half right and neither half helps the league table.
What did the pundits make of the decision?
Former Forest boss Steve Cooper, working for Sky Sports, split the difference neatly. He said Bramall should have given a free kick straight away, calling it as clear a free kick as any in the whole game, which is exactly Gibbs-White’s point about on-pitch ownership. On the card itself, Cooper predicted the split: “The red card will split decision. Forest fans and staff and players will feel hard done by but if it had gone against Ipswich, they would definitely have felt hard done by.” The Soucek VAR row earlier this season followed the same script, and neither incident has moved the debate forward.
Is VAR really Forest’s problem?
The data says the finishing is. Forest created 2.31 expected goals at Ipswich and won the shot count 17-7, yet had only Williams’s goal to show for it. Across the season they have scored six times from 13.4 expected goals, the worst underperformance in the Premier League, and they have one win from eight games. Liam Delap, against his former club, headed over and drilled a 30-yarder fractionally wide. Leif Davis cleared off the line twice. Add a worrying arm injury for Williams late on, and Ipswich leave with a point that gives them as many home points this season as they managed in all of 2024/25. The VAR debate is the loud story, but as Gibbs-White himself admitted, the quiet one is the shooting. That is also why the club’s injury list matters more than the officials this weekend: Forest cannot afford to lose their goalscorers when the goals are this hard to come by.
Frequently asked questions
What happened in the VAR incident at Ipswich?+
In the 49th minute, Ipswich defender Issa Diop fouled Nottingham Forest's James McAtee as he raced through on goal. Referee Thomas Bramall waved play on, VAR advised a review for denying a clear goalscoring opportunity, and Bramall went to the pitchside monitor. He announced a direct free kick and a yellow card for Diop, ruling that McAtee had knocked the ball to the right side of the goal with Leif Davis covering.
What did Morgan Gibbs-White say about VAR?+
The Forest captain told Sky Sports: 'My only question is why does that have to go to VAR when the referee and linesman are standing there? That shouldn't be going to VAR; they should be giving that. There needs to be some ownership on the pitch for me; the referee and linesman can see that.' He added that the officials were not the reason Forest failed to win.
Did Gibbs-White think Diop should have been sent off?+
No. He said the yellow was probably the right call, and noted that Leif Davis might have been getting back to cover the goal, which undercuts the denial-of-a-goalscoring-opportunity argument. His complaint was about the process, not the punishment, which puts him at odds with his own manager on the red-card question.
What did Oliver Glasner say?+
Forest's boss said: 'It felt during the game it's a clear red card. I think it was the wrong decision.' So the two most senior figures at the club left Portman Road disagreeing: the captain defended the yellow but attacked the VAR process, while the manager wanted the red and called the decision wrong.
What did the pundits make of the decision?+
Former Forest boss Steve Cooper, on Sky Sports, said Bramall should have given a free kick straight away, calling it as clear a free kick as any in the game, and predicted the red card would split opinion. He added that Forest would feel hard done by, but Ipswich would have felt the same had it gone the other way.
Is VAR Forest's real problem?+
The numbers say no. Forest created 2.31 expected goals and won the shot count 17-7 at Ipswich but scored once. They have scored just six goals from 13.4 expected goals this season, the worst underperformance in the league, and have one win from eight games. Gibbs-White himself said the players must own the chances they missed.
What were the other key moments at Portman Road?+
Neco Williams gave Forest a deserved 13th-minute lead from Daniel Munoz's cross, Julio Enciso equalised before half-time after a Nikola Milenkovic error, Leif Davis cleared off the line twice for Ipswich, Liam Delap missed big chances against his former club, and Williams later left with a worrying arm injury.
Sources
- Sky Sports: Ipswich 1-1 Nottingham Forest match report (the Diop VAR sequence, Bramall's monitor announcement, the Glasner 'clear red card' quote, the Gibbs-White 'probably right' framing, the xG and shot data)
- Nottingham Forest News: Gibbs-White wants change after the VAR call (the full 'why does that have to go to VAR' quote, the ownership-on-the-pitch argument, the Leif Davis covering detail)
- Tribal Football: Glasner slams officials for the Diop decision (the captain-versus-manager split on the same incident, the clear-red-card claim)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 38-0 — Sign a 4-4-2 of all-time football legends and chase a perfect 38-0 league season — perfect, not just unbeaten.
- Explore all our games →
Related football guides
View all →
Why Did Marmoush's Goal Stand After He Caught Van Ewijk With an Elbow?
Omar Marmoush's first Tottenham goal survived a VAR check for an elbow on Milan van Ewijk. Lampard thought it would go; Hackett says doubt means it stands.
Why Could VAR Not Send Off Morgan Rogers at Everton?
Three former referees said Morgan Rogers should have been punished for his tackle on James Garner at Everton. VAR could not give him a second yellow. Here is why.
Madueke's Deflected Strike Gives Arsenal a 1-0 Win at Forest With Their Only Shot on Target
Noni Madueke's deflected 80th-minute strike gave Arsenal a 1-0 win at Nottingham Forest with their only shot on target, sending Forest into the relegation zone.
Botman Escapes a Red Card at Newcastle as Jackson Says He Nearly Broke His Leg
Sven Botman stayed on after a VAR check for serious foul play against Aston Villa, with the referee's own published words calling the challenge reckless.
Yarmolyuk's Headbutt Earns a Red Card but No Penalty as Liverpool Beat Brentford 2-1
Yehor Yarmolyuk was sent off for a headbutting action on Jeremy Jacquet before a corner at Brentford, and Liverpool got no penalty because the ball was dead.
Brennan Johnson's Goal at Hull Is Ruled Out by a Subjective Offside Everton Have Seen Before
Brennan Johnson's goal for Everton at Hull was disallowed after a VAR review for a subjective offside, his second disallowed-goal controversy in two games.