Haaland Sees Equaliser Ruled Out as VAR Backs Leno Call in Man City's Draw With Fulham
On this page6
Erling Haaland thought he had dragged Manchester City level against Fulham, wheeled away in celebration, and then watched the goal disappear. Referee Tom Bramall ruled in the 25th minute that Haaland had kicked the ball out of Bernd Leno’s hands, VAR checked the call and confirmed it, and the Premier League Match Centre published the explanation while the debate was still raging. It finished 1-1, and City’s wait for a league win goes on.
What happened in the 25th minute?
A cross, a fumble and a bundle. Phil Foden found Iliman Ndiaye on the right, Ndiaye crossed to the far post, and Haaland slid in at the second attempt after Leno failed to gather his first effort. The Norwegian poked the ball home and celebrated, but Bramall had already blown for a free-kick to Fulham. Replays showed Leno appeared to have both hands on the ball, although there were questions over whether the Fulham goalkeeper was actually in control of it, and the incident came nine minutes after Rodrigo Muniz had given Fulham a shock 16th-minute lead at the Etihad. City went into the game on the back of three straight league defeats, and the disallowed goal was the moment the afternoon threatened to turn.
What did the Premier League say?
The league did not wait for the post-match inquest. The Premier League Match Centre posted on X: “The referee’s call of free-kick to Fulham and no goal to Manchester City was checked and confirmed by VAR, with the goalkeeper deemed to be in control of the ball.” The VAR audio quoted in the post added: “The ball is in control between both hands and then is played out of that possession by the attacker, and then into the back of the net.” That is the whole case in two sentences, and it is why the officials felt they had no choice.
Why do the experts disagree?
Because the law is clear and the pictures are not. ESPN rules expert Dale Johnson backed the decision without hesitation, writing that Haaland’s goal had to be disallowed because Leno had the ball between his hands when Haaland made first contact. “It’s an automatic free-kick,” Johnson said. “The ‘level’ of the goalkeeper’s control is irrelevant.” Under IFAB Law 12, a goalkeeper is considered in control of the ball when it is between their hands or arms, or between their hands and any surface, and an opponent cannot challenge for it in that position. TNT Sports pundit Joe Cole saw it the other way. “He’s not got it. His palms are open,” Cole said on air. “I can understand the referees thinking they’ve got the right decision but it never seemed to me like he had control of the ball.” Fans split the same way online, with some calling it daylight robbery and others pointing out that two hands on the ball is two hands on the ball. It is the same kind of VAR argument that split opinion over Ryan Gravenberch’s red card earlier in the season, where the first yellow looked harsh and the second looked clear.
How did Haaland and Maresca react?
Haaland could not believe it, and Maresca could not hide it either. The striker was visibly furious as the decision stood, and the City head coach objected to the fourth official, with lip readers picking up the words “It’s not a foul, oh my god.” The frustration spread through the stadium: the home fans booed City off at half-time with the score still 0-1, and goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma was booked in the 76th minute for his complaints to the referee. It was that kind of afternoon for City, whose striker had already missed two big chances before the break, blazing over from the left of the box in the 36th minute and dragging another effort wide in the 41st, after a header had been cleared off the line in the opening minutes.
What happened after the disallowed goal?
City eventually found a way through, just not through Haaland. Elliot Anderson levelled in the 57th minute, volleying home from the edge of the box after a City corner was headed out, his first league goal for the club since a £116 million summer arrival. Donnarumma then had to make a huge save from Muniz in the 68th minute as Fulham broke two-on-two, and Maresca sent on Allan and Gvardiol in a double change in the 78th minute as City chased a winner. No late winner came for either side, and it finished 1-1. Arsenal, six points clear at the top before kick-off, travel to Newcastle later on Saturday, and a City draw would leave the gap exactly where it was.
What does this mean for City’s title race?
The draw means City have now gone four league games without a win, and the gap to Arsenal stays at six points until Arsenal play Newcastle later on Saturday, when it could stretch to nine. What is not in doubt is the direction of travel: three successive Premier League defeats to Brighton, Aston Villa and Nottingham Forest had already left City third and six points behind Arsenal, and this was supposed to be the reset after the international break. Instead the lunchtime kick-off produced a disallowed goal, a furious striker, a booked goalkeeper and boos at half-time. Maresca had already spent the break defending his players over the 115 charges case, and he now has a different argument to make: that his team did enough to win a game the officials would not let them level when it mattered. The table will not care about the argument. Liverpool host Manchester United at Anfield on Sunday, and City will be watching that one closely: a Liverpool win would keep the pressure on Arsenal, while anything else would leave City further adrift before their next league game.
Frequently asked questions
Why was Erling Haaland's goal disallowed?+
Haaland bundled the ball home in the 25th minute after Bernd Leno failed to gather his first effort, but referee Tom Bramall ruled that Haaland had kicked the ball out of the Fulham goalkeeper's hands. Under the laws of the game, a goalkeeper is considered in control of the ball when it is between their hands, and an attacker cannot play it out of their possession. VAR checked the decision and confirmed it.
What did the Premier League say about the decision?+
The Premier League Match Centre posted on X that the referee's call of a free-kick to Fulham and no goal to Manchester City was checked and confirmed by VAR, with the goalkeeper deemed to be in control of the ball. The VAR audio quoted in the post said the ball was in control between both hands and then was played out of that possession by the attacker.
Did the experts agree with the call?+
Not all of them. ESPN rules expert Dale Johnson said Haaland's goal had to be disallowed because Leno had the ball between his hands when Haaland made first contact, calling it an automatic free-kick and adding that the level of the goalkeeper's control is irrelevant. TNT Sports pundit Joe Cole disagreed, saying Leno's palms were open and he never seemed to have control of the ball.
How did Haaland and Maresca react?+
Haaland wheeled away in celebration before realising the goal had been chalked off, and he was visibly furious. City head coach Enzo Maresca objected to the fourth official, with lip readers picking up 'It's not a foul, oh my god.' The home crowd booed City off at half-time, and goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma was booked in the 76th minute for his complaints to the referee.
What was the final score?+
Manchester City drew 1-1 with Fulham at the Etihad. Rodrigo Muniz gave Fulham a shock 16th-minute lead, and Elliot Anderson levelled for City in the 57th minute with a volley from the edge of the box, his first league goal for the club since a £116 million summer move. No late winner came for either side.
What does the result mean for Manchester City's title hopes?+
City went into the lunchtime kick-off third in the table, six points behind leaders Arsenal, after three successive Premier League defeats to Brighton, Aston Villa and Nottingham Forest. A draw leaves them still searching for a first league win in four matches, with Arsenal able to stretch the gap to nine points when they travel to Newcastle later on Saturday.
How many goals has Haaland scored this season?+
Nine in 10 Premier League games before this match, which is why the disallowed goal stung. Haaland had already missed two big chances in the first half, blazing over from the left of the box in the 36th minute and dragging another effort wide in the 41st, and he had a header cleared off the line in the opening minutes.
Has this rule caused controversy before?+
Yes, and that is why the debate split so fast. The law is black and white on paper: two hands on the ball means the goalkeeper is in control, and the level of that control does not matter. But fans and pundits argue about what counts as control when a goalkeeper is still gathering a loose ball, which is exactly the grey area Leno's fumble sat in.
Sources
- talkSPORT: Why Erling Haaland's goal had to be disallowed as explanation emerges (the 25th-minute incident, Bramall's call, the Premier League Match Centre explanation, Dale Johnson backing the decision, City's three straight defeats, Anderson's 57th-minute equaliser)
- The Times: Premier League live (the Foden-to-Ndiaye build-up, Haaland's celebration cut short, Maresca's 'It's not a foul, oh my god', the half-time boos, Haaland's missed chances)
- The Sun: Major controversy as Erling Haaland's goal is RULED OUT in Man City vs Fulham (Joe Cole's 'He's not got it, his palms are open', the fan split on social media, the IFAB Law 12 wording, Haaland's nine league goals)
- GiveMeSport: Premier League issue statement after Erling Haaland has goal ruled out vs Fulham (the full Match Centre statement, the VAR audio, the Law 12 control definition, City's three-match winless run)
- Hayters: Man City v Fulham LIVE (the minute-by-minute account, Donnarumma's 76th-minute booking, the 68th-minute save from Muniz, the double change in the 78th minute)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 38-0 — Sign a 4-4-2 of all-time football legends and chase a perfect 38-0 league season — perfect, not just unbeaten.
- Explore all our games →
Related football guides
View all →
Lammens Blocks Suzuki, Emery Walks Out Early and Carrick Refuses to Quit in Man Utd's 4-4 Villa Draw
Senne Lammens backed into Zion Suzuki at the corner that produced Patrick Dorgu's 96th-minute equaliser, VAR let it stand, Emery walked out early and Carrick refused to quit.
Ex-Refs Chief Calls It 'Deliberate': City Denied Clear Penalty in Brighton Defeat
Former PGMOL head Keith Hackett says Manchester City should have had a penalty for Luka Vuskovic's handball in Saturday's 1-0 loss to Brighton.
Calvert-Lewin's Goal Ruled Out for Handball as Trafford Error Gifts Bournemouth 2-0 Win Over Leeds
Dominic Calvert-Lewin saw an 11th-minute goal ruled out for handball by VAR, then James Trafford gifted Evanilson the opener as Bournemouth beat Leeds 2-0.
Brennan Johnson's Goal at Hull Is Ruled Out by a Subjective Offside Everton Have Seen Before
Brennan Johnson's goal for Everton at Hull was disallowed after a VAR review for a subjective offside, his second disallowed-goal controversy in two games.
Thiago Sees Yellow Turned to Red as Brentford Lose Down to 10 Again
Igor Thiago was sent off after VAR upgraded Michael Oliver's yellow card to red in Brentford's 2-0 defeat at Brighton, and he laughed as he walked off.
Premier League Clubs Push for a New Man City Investigation Into the Post-2018 Years
English football executives are pushing for Manchester City to be investigated over the seasons since 2018, The Independent reports, asking whether the sponsorship deals at the heart of the 115-charges case simply stopped.