Caleb Williams Keeps Wearing the Cleats the NFL Fined Him For
On this page8
- 01What exactly was Williams fined for?
- 02Why does Williams think the shoes are safer?
- 03Why was he not fined in Weeks 1 and 2?
- 04What has Caddix offered to do?
- 05What did Williams do in the game that drew the fine?
- 06What happens next?
- 07October 30 update: the second fine lands, and Williams is not covering the logo
- 08October 31 update: Flacco offers to pay, and the hearing gets a date
The NFL fined Caleb Williams $11,941 for a logo on his shoes, and the Chicago Bears quarterback’s answer, in effect, is to keep wearing the shoes. Williams has appealed the fine, arguing that he believes his Caddix cleats are safer than the league’s officially licensed options, and he wore the same cleats again in Week 7. Caddix, the company that makes them, says Williams bought the cleats himself, holds no endorsement deal with the brand, and has offered to pay the fine anyway. So the league has a rule, the player has a safety argument, and the brand has a checkbook. Something has to give, and on Monday night against Seattle, everyone will be looking at his feet.
What exactly was Williams fined for?
A visible logo, not a shoe. The NFL fined Williams $11,941 for displaying an unauthorized logo on his shoes during the Week 6 win over the Atlanta Falcons, Pro Football Talk reports. Williams was wearing Caddix cleats, which do not have a deal with the NFL for the use of its shoes in games. The league only has footwear partnerships with Nike, Adidas and Under Armour, talkSPORT reports, so anyone wearing another brand has to hide the logo. NBC Chicago’s James Neveau noted that the fine came from Williams not covering the Caddix logo, talkSPORT reports. The distinction matters, because it is the whole fight in miniature: the league is not saying the cleats are dangerous or illegal as footwear. It is saying the logo is not allowed to show.
Why does Williams think the shoes are safer?
Because of what is under them. Williams’s appeal argument, as Pro Football Talk reports it, is that he believes the shoes are safer than the shoe options officially licensed by the NFL. Caddix founder Jack Rasmussen explained the claim to talkSPORT: Williams bought the cleats because they are the only ones built with SmartStuds, which release under injurious load, reducing the force responsible for non-contact knee and ankle injuries. That is a marketing claim from the company selling the shoes, and it should be read as one. But it is also the reason this fine is more interesting than a normal uniform violation. If a player subjectively believes a non-partner shoe is safer, Pro Football Talk asks, should the league prevent him from wearing it? And if objective data ever backed the claim, the report adds, it would be another case of health-and-safety commitments yielding to dollars and cents.
Why was he not fined in Weeks 1 and 2?
Because of the color of the shoes. Williams has worn the same type of shoe throughout the preseason and in every regular-season game he has played, Pro Football Talk reports, and he was not fined for Week 1 or Week 2. The explanation, from NBC Chicago reporting carried by RG.org, is that he wore white Caddix cleats in those weeks, when the logo was not visible, and switched to a black pair for Weeks 6 and 7, when it could be seen. That detail turns the fine into something close to a loophole story: the same shoes, the same player, fined only when the logo shows. It also raises the obvious question for Monday night. If Williams wears the white pair against Seattle, is the problem solved, or does the league then have to decide whether it is fining a logo or a brand?
What has Caddix offered to do?
Pay, for as long as it takes. Rasmussen said the company will cover the fine, talkSPORT reports, and Heavy reports Caddix says it will pay future fines too if Williams keeps wearing the cleats. The company is careful to add that Williams bought the cleats himself and has no endorsement deal with the brand. That matters for the story’s credibility: this is not a paid ambassador defying a sponsor rule for a sponsor. It is a customer who prefers a product, a company happy to fund the defiance, and a league rule that was written for a world where players wore whatever their sponsor paid them to wear. A second offense for an unauthorized logo carries a $23,882 fine under league rules, NBC Chicago reports, so the price of the standoff doubles if it continues.
What did Williams do in the game that drew the fine?
He won it, coming back from injury. Week 6 at Atlanta was Williams’s first game back after a hamstring injury suffered against the Minnesota Vikings, talkSPORT reports, and he threw for 305 yards and a touchdown in Chicago’s 31-23 win. Since his return he has thrown for 613 yards and three touchdowns, talkSPORT reports. The timing is part of why the fine landed awkwardly: a quarterback returning from injury, choosing shoes he believes protect his knees and ankles, fined for the logo on them. Williams has been no stranger to making his own headlines in Chicago, having earlier this month called every injury report about him wrong, and the league has shown it will walk back a fine when the case shifts, as it did when it rescinded Juszczyk’s juice-box fine. The Carter punch case from Monday Night Football shows the other side of the same system: a fine looming before it is even announced. And the Vrabel fine saga showed how quickly a fine story becomes a referendum on the league’s judgment rather than the act itself.
What happens next?
Monday night, and then the appeal. The Bears return to action against the Seattle Seahawks on Monday night, Pro Football Talk reports, and it will make plenty of sense to eyeball what Williams has on his feet. That Week 7 fine has now landed: $23,882, double the Week 6 figure, as detailed in the October 30 update below, so Caddix’s promise gets its first real test on Monday night. If the appeal succeeds, the league will have to explain how a safety argument beats a sponsorship rule. Either way, the interesting part is no longer the $11,941. It is whether a logo rule written for sponsors can survive a player who says he is wearing the shoes for his knees, and a company willing to pay for him to keep saying it.
October 30 update: the second fine lands, and Williams is not covering the logo
The bill has doubled, and so has the defiance. The NFL fined Williams $23,882 for sporting Caddix cleats in the Week 7 game against the New England Patriots, a source confirmed to ESPN on Thursday, with Pro Football Talk first reporting the news. The fine is exactly double the $11,941 he received for the Week 6 game at Atlanta, and it was issued for the same reason: the visible logo of a brand that has no footwear deal with the league. Williams told ESPN on Wednesday that he does not plan to cover or black out the Caddix logo when he wears the cleats for Chicago’s game at the Seattle Seahawks on Monday, which sets up the next test of the standoff in prime time.
The context around the second fine also fills in the picture the first fine left incomplete. Williams wore Caddix cleats throughout the preseason and during Chicago’s first two regular-season games, TSN reports, then missed Weeks 3 through 5 with a hamstring injury before returning against Atlanta and New England. He became the first Bears quarterback since Mitchell Trubisky in 2018 to record back-to-back 300-yard passing games, which is why the shoes-versus-logo argument keeps travelling: the player says the cleats, built around patented SmartStuds designed to flex and release during cutting and pivoting, are why his joints, ankles, knees and feet have not bothered him as much as with other cleats. “I try to be healthy. They’re smart cleats. They’re science cleats, and they’ve been working for me,” Williams said. Caddix founder Jack Rasmussen repeated the company’s offer in a statement to ESPN: “From a safety metric perspective, Caleb’s cleats are one of the safest pairs players can wear. Regardless if this is a marketing fine or not, I’m happy to pay it.” For The Win adds, via ESPN, that Caddix has a hearing with the NFL next month to seek league approval, which is the first date on the calendar where this stops being a fine-by-fine fight and becomes a ruling on the shoes themselves.
October 31 update: Flacco offers to pay, and the hearing gets a date
The standoff has gained a second wallet. Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Flacco has offered to pay any future fines Williams receives for wearing Caddix cleats, EssentiallySports reports, in a statement to ESPN: “If Caleb gets fined again for wearing Caddix, I’ll pay the fine myself. I’ve worn these cleats for years, and I know firsthand the difference they make. When you’re playing at this level, you need equipment you can trust. This isn’t about making a statement or breaking the rules just to break them. It’s about wearing gear that works for you and helps keep you safe on the field. If Caleb believes in Caddix the way I do, I’m happy to stand behind him.”
The offer comes with a disclosure the reader should have. Flacco is not a neutral admirer: he is an advisor and investor in Caddix, EssentiallySports reports, and RG.org notes he is one of four athlete advisors to the company. That does not invalidate the offer, but it changes its shape. Caddix’s founder paying a player’s fine is a company standing behind its product. A veteran quarterback who has a stake in the company paying a younger quarterback’s fine is also a marketing story, and the league will read it that way if the fight reaches the hearing room.
The hearing now has a date to go with it. RG.org reports, via ESPN, that Caddix has a November 10 hearing with the NFL, and that the company plans to pay the Week 6 fine if Williams’s appeal fails. That date is the first point where this stops being a fine-by-fine standoff and becomes a ruling on whether a non-partner shoe with a safety claim can earn league approval. Before that comes Monday night at Seattle, where Williams has already said he will wear the logo uncovered. If the league fines him a third time, the fine schedule points to another doubling, and for the first time there are two parties publicly offering to pay it.
Frequently asked questions
How much was Caleb Williams fined, and for what?+
The NFL fined Williams $11,941 for displaying an unauthorized logo on his shoes during the Week 6 win over the Atlanta Falcons, Pro Football Talk reports. The issue was not the cleats themselves but the visible Caddix logo: Caddix has no footwear deal with the NFL, and league rules require players to cover logos from brands without a league marketing deal.
Why does Williams say the cleats are safer?+
Williams's appeal argument is that he believes the Caddix shoes are safer than the officially licensed options, Pro Football Talk reports. Caddix founder Jack Rasmussen says Williams bought the cleats because they are built with SmartStuds, which release under injurious load to reduce the force responsible for non-contact knee and ankle injuries, talkSPORT reports.
Why was Williams not fined earlier in the season?+
Williams wore the same type of shoe throughout the preseason and in every regular-season game he has played, Pro Football Talk reports. He was not fined for Weeks 1 and 2, when he wore white Caddix cleats on which the logo was not visible, and he switched to a black pair for Weeks 6 and 7, when the logo could be seen, according to NBC Chicago reporting carried by RG.org.
Has Williams been fined for the Week 7 game too?+
Yes, as of October 30. The NFL fined Williams $23,882 for sporting Caddix cleats in the Week 7 game against the New England Patriots, a source confirmed to ESPN on Thursday, and Pro Football Talk first reported the news. That is double the $11,941 Week 6 fine. Williams told ESPN on Wednesday that he does not plan to cover or black out the Caddix logo when he wears the cleats for Chicago's game at the Seattle Seahawks on Monday, and Caddix says the company will pay if Williams loses his appeal.
Is Caddix paying Williams's fine?+
The company has offered to. Rasmussen said Caddix will cover the fine, and Heavy reports the company says it will pay future fines too if Williams keeps wearing the cleats. Caddix also stresses Williams bought the cleats himself and has no endorsement deal with the brand, a point Complex Sneakers also reported from the company's response.
What did Williams do in the Week 6 game itself?+
It was his first game back after a hamstring injury suffered against the Minnesota Vikings, talkSPORT reports. He threw for 305 yards and a touchdown as Chicago beat Atlanta 31-23. Since his return he has thrown for 613 yards and three touchdowns, talkSPORT reports.
Can the NFL stop Williams from wearing the cleats?+
The fine letter, dated October 20, does not mention preventing Williams from playing with the Caddix logo visible, Pro Football Talk reports. That leaves the standoff where it is: Williams appealing and intending to keep wearing the shoes, Caddix offering to pay, and the league's partner-only logo rule still on the books.
When will everyone see what Williams wears next?+
Monday night, when the Bears return to action against the Seattle Seahawks, Pro Football Talk reports. As the report puts it, it will make plenty of sense to eyeball the items Williams has on his feet, since a second visible-logo game would test both the appeal and Caddix's promise to pay.
Has anyone else offered to pay Williams's fines?+
Yes: Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Flacco, who is an advisor and investor in Caddix and has worn the brand's cleats since 2024, EssentiallySports reports. In a statement to ESPN, Flacco said: 'If Caleb gets fined again for wearing Caddix, I'll pay the fine myself. I've worn these cleats for years, and I know firsthand the difference they make.' The distinction matters: Caddix has offered to cover the fines already issued, while Flacco's offer covers the next one, which would land if Williams wears the logo uncovered at Seattle on Monday night.
Sources
- NBC Sports (Pro Football Talk): NFL fines Caleb Williams $11,941 for displaying 'unauthorized logo' on his shoes in Week 6 (the fine amount, the appeal and safety argument, the intention to keep wearing the shoes, the October 20 fine letter, the Seahawks game)
- talkSPORT: Caleb Williams fined $11,941 for displaying 'unauthorized logo' in Bears game as brand steps in (the Week 6 return from injury, 305 yards and a touchdown, Caddix covering the fine, Rasmussen on SmartStuds, the Week 7 repeat)
- Heavy: Bears QB Caleb Williams sends defiant message to NFL after fine (the appeal, the plan to keep wearing the cleats, Caddix paying future fines)
- RG.org: Caleb Williams fined $11,941 over Caddix cleats logo (the white cleats in Weeks 1 and 2, the black pair in Weeks 6 and 7, the $23,882 second-offense figure, Rasmussen's offer)
- TSN (ESPN): Report: Bears QB Williams fined again for cleats (the $23,882 Week 7 fine, the plan to wear the cleats uncovered at Seattle, the appeal, Rasmussen's safety statement, the back-to-back 300-yard games)
- For The Win (USA Today): Why Caleb Williams will continue to wear unapproved cleats despite NFL fines (the intention to keep wearing the cleats, the Caddix hearing with the NFL next month)
- EssentiallySports: 'I've Worn These Cleats for Years' (Flacco's offer to pay future fines, his advisor and investor role, his cleats since 2024, Rasmussen restating that Caddix will cover the fines)
- RG.org: Caleb Williams to Keep Wearing Caddix Cleats After NFL Fine (Flacco as one of four Caddix athlete advisors, the November 10 hearing with the NFL, Caddix paying the Week 6 fine if the appeal fails)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 17-0 — Draft nine and chase a flawless NFL regular season — the perfect 17-0 run, no playoffs.
- Play 20-0 — Draft nine and chase a perfect NFL season — regular season and playoffs, undefeated.
- Play 16-0 — Draft nine and chase a perfect 16-0 — the classic 16-game NFL regular season, no playoffs.
- Play Flawless Six — Draft five players and a head coach, then chase a perfect NFL season with the right chemistry.
- Play Guess the NFL Player — A new mystery NFL player every day. Eight guesses, with a clue on each — plus free unlimited mode.
- Play NFL Wordle — A Wordle for football — guess the daily NFL player in eight tries, with green-amber-grey feedback on every clue.
- Play NFL Connections — Sort sixteen football tiles into four hidden groups of four. A new daily puzzle, four mistakes allowed, plus unlimited mode.
- Explore all our games →
- Open the schedule simulator — Pick every 2026 NFL game and watch the standings and playoff seeds update live.
- Open the squares generator — Generate a randomized, printable Super Bowl squares grid for your party — free, no sign-up.
- Open the trade calculator — Weigh any fantasy football trade instantly — clear winner and value gap.
- Run the NFL predictor — Simulate the NFL bracket and see who your picks send to the Super Bowl.
- Open the passer rating calculator — Calculate the official NFL passer rating (0–158.3) from any passing line, with the formula shown.
- Explore all our free sports tools →
Related nfl guides
View all →
Caleb Williams Calls Every Injury Report Wrong and Refuses to Give the Real Grade
Caleb Williams returned to Bears practice, said his hamstring injury was a serious tear, and refused to share its grade because the earlier reports were wrong.
Santos Appears to Try to Trip Golden After He Flattened a Bears Coach
Bears kicker Cairo Santos stuck a leg out at Packers returner Matthew Golden seconds after Golden ran over a Chicago coach on the sideline, and no flag was thrown for either act.
NFL Rescinds Juszczyk's $14,926 Juice-Box Fine and Allows Drinking Celebrations
The NFL has rescinded Kyle Juszczyk's $14,926 fine, accepted his juice-box explanation, and said drinking celebrations will no longer be disciplined.
FAA Ground Stop Strands College Teams and Puts NFL Weekend Travel on Watch
The FAA grounded every departing flight in the United States on Friday afternoon, stranding college football teams and forcing some onto buses before lifting the stop after about four hours.
Overshown Runs Onto Field in Sweats a Day After His $9,528 Fine
Inactive Cowboys linebacker DeMarvion Overshown ran onto the field in street clothes to celebrate a fumble in Dallas's 27-23 win at Indianapolis, a day after the NFL fined him $9,528.
Roquan Smith Fined $35,822 for Two Unflagged Hits on Bills
The NFL fined Ravens linebacker Roquan Smith $17,911 twice for two unflagged plays against the Bills: a facemask on Josh Allen and a hit on DJ Moore.