SportsMonkie.com
NFL

Aaron Glenn: 'If That Was Josh Allen, Every Flag Would Be Thrown'

By SportsMonkie NFL Desk Updated November 16, 2026
File photo from 23 July 2025: Aaron Glenn speaking to the media at New York Jets training camp. It does not show the Bills game.
Image: 2025 NYJ HC Aaron Glenn by New York Jets · via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)
Share this guide
On this page6
  1. 01What happened on the hit to Geno Smith?
  2. 02What exactly did Glenn say to the officials?
  3. 03Was the no-call the right decision?
  4. 04What did Glenn say after the game?
  5. 05How did fans react to the clip?
  6. 06What happens next for Smith and the Jets?

Aaron Glenn said out loud what a lot of Jets fans have been thinking all season. With his quarterback down after an unflagged high-low hit, the Jets coach walked up to the officials at halftime of Sunday’s 31-12 loss to Buffalo and told them Josh Allen would have drawn every flag in the building. The clip travelled within minutes, and by Monday Smith was having imaging tests on an ankle injury while Glenn’s job security was the other half of the conversation.

What happened on the hit to Geno Smith?

The Jets were driving late in the first half, facing third-and-4 from the Bills 9, when Smith rolled to his right and threw a jump pass toward the end zone that fell incomplete. Linebacker Terrel Bernard smacked into him high with his right shoulder as the quarterback was in the air, while rookie T.J. Parker dove at his knees, Awful Announcing reports. Smith stayed on his back for a few minutes, was looked at by trainers, and headed to the injury tent. No penalty was called on the play. It was not the first time this season that a hit on a Bills quarterback went unflagged: the league fined Roquan Smith $35,822 for two unflagged hits earlier this season, and the running argument about which hits draw flags has followed the officials all year.

What exactly did Glenn say to the officials?

CBS cameras caught the 54-year-old excoriating referee Ron Torbert and his crew as the teams filed off the field at halftime, Awful Announcing reports. Glenn did not argue the rulebook. He challenged the officials to imagine the same hit on Buffalo’s quarterback. “Here’s my problem with that: if that was Josh Allen, every flag on the field would be thrown,” Glenn can be seen telling them. It was the second halftime episode of Glenn’s season: last month he assured sideline reporter Aditi Kinkhabwala that the Jets would receive the ball to open the second half against the Patriots, only for New England to take the kickoff, and the team’s livestream of his next press conference went dark when a reporter asked about it.

Was the no-call the right decision?

The rulebook gives both sides something to hold. Smith had left the pocket, which strips a passer of some of his special protections, including the one against low hits. But he had stopped behind the line of scrimmage and reset to throw before Bernard and Parker arrived, and the rulebook restores all of a passer’s protections once he does that, Awful Announcing reports. CBS rules analyst Gene Steratore still backed the crew, saying Bernard led with his right shoulder, kept the contact below the head and neck area, and initiated the tackle as Smith was releasing the ball. The fans who watched the clip were less persuaded. “No lies detected,” one wrote after Awful Announcing shared the video, Pro Football Network reports, while another added that it is no secret certain quarterbacks get special treatment.

What did Glenn say after the game?

He did not hide his frustration. “Absolutely, I’m frustrated,” Glenn said, adding that it is “hard to win games when you operate that way,” according to the New York Post. The context makes the outburst harder to dismiss as a one-off. Glenn is 5-22 since taking over in 2025, the Jets are 0-9 against AFC East opponents under him, and he is the sixth head coach since the 1970 merger to start his tenure 0-9 in division games, Men’s Journal reports. The criticism has come from inside the franchise’s own history too: after the Raiders loss, Minkah Fitzpatrick’s “Jets being Jets” line went viral, and Rex Ryan, the last coach to win a playoff game for the franchise, said Fitzpatrick is “a shell of himself”. Coaches have been clashing with officials all season: Mike Vrabel was flagged and fined after calling a referee “a little sensitive” during the Patriots’ win over Buffalo, and Todd Bowles called out the league’s most flag-happy crew after the Buccaneers survived 14 penalties in Dallas. Glenn’s version was the loudest of the lot because it named the star at the centre of the double standard.

How did fans react to the clip?

They mostly sided with the coach of a 2-8 team. The clip spread quickly after Awful Announcing posted it, and the replies backed Glenn’s complaint that some quarterbacks receive more favourable treatment than others, Pro Football Network reports. “AG is 100% right,” radio host Jeff Parles wrote, while another fan called it the realest thing Glenn has said as Jets head coach. The reaction matters because it shows how the argument has shifted: the question fans are now asking is not whether the hit was legal, but whether the same hit on Allen would have been judged the same way.

What happens next for Smith and the Jets?

The imaging comes first. Smith, rookie receiver Omar Cooper Jr. and left guard Dylan Parham were all having tests on Monday, and Glenn said he would have updates later in the week, theScore reports. Smith cleared the concussion protocol and returned for one series before leaving again in the third quarter, when his left ankle rolled under him on a hit from safety Cole Bishop. Glenn said Smith remains the starter when healthy, but rookie Cade Klubnik would fill in if he cannot go on Sunday against the Chargers in Los Angeles. Klubnik, a fourth-round pick out of Clemson, went 11 of 20 for 137 yards with an interception in relief, and Glenn praised his poise. Smith was 13 of 21 for 148 yards before leaving, and has thrown for 2,226 yards and 12 touchdowns with three interceptions this season. Allen, meanwhile, finished 11 of 21 for 196 yards with one touchdown pass and two more on the ground as Buffalo improved to 8-1, its best start since 1991. The Jets have now gone nine quarters without a touchdown, and the quarterback question is only the most urgent of several.

Share this article

Frequently asked questions

What did Aaron Glenn say to the officials?+

As the teams left the field at halftime, CBS cameras caught Glenn telling referee Ron Torbert's crew, 'Here's my problem with that: if that was Josh Allen, every flag on the field would be thrown.' He was arguing that the same high-low hit on Buffalo's quarterback would have drawn a roughing-the-passer flag.

What happened to Geno Smith on the play?+

Late in the first half, on third-and-4 from the Bills 9, Smith rolled right and threw a jump pass toward the end zone. Linebacker Terrel Bernard hit him high with his right shoulder while rookie T.J. Parker dove at his knees. Smith stayed down for a few minutes, was looked at by trainers, and went to the injury tent for a concussion evaluation.

Was the hit actually a penalty?+

That is the argument. CBS rules analyst Gene Steratore backed the officials, saying Bernard led with his shoulder below the head and neck area and made contact as Smith released the ball. But Smith had reset behind the line to throw, which restores a passer's protections, and two defenders converging from opposite ends looked like a flag to most viewers.

Has Glenn been punished for the outburst?+

No fine had been announced by Monday. Glenn has been in this territory before: the league fined him $250,000 earlier this season, along with Mike Vrabel and Nick Sirianni, Patriots Wire reports. Vrabel was also flagged on the field after calling a referee 'a little sensitive' during the Patriots' win over Buffalo. Any fine for Sunday's comments would land this week.

How bad are the Jets this season?+

They are 2-8 after a fifth straight loss, and Glenn is 5-22 since taking over in 2025. The Jets are 0-9 against AFC East opponents under Glenn, making him the sixth head coach since the 1970 merger to start his tenure 0-9 in division games. They have now gone nine quarters without scoring a touchdown.

What is Geno Smith's injury status?+

Smith was having imaging tests on his left ankle on Monday, and it is uncertain whether he can play Sunday against the Chargers in Los Angeles. He cleared the concussion protocol and returned for one series before leaving again in the third quarter, when his ankle rolled under him on a hit from safety Cole Bishop.

How did fans react to Glenn's comment?+

Mostly with agreement. After Awful Announcing shared the clip, fans replied 'No lies detected' and 'it's no secret certain QBs get special treatment,' while one observer wrote that Glenn 'is many things' but 'in this instance, he is not wrong.' The clip became the weekend's loudest officiating argument.

Sources

Play & tools

Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.

  • Play 17-0 — Draft nine and chase a flawless NFL regular season — the perfect 17-0 run, no playoffs.
  • Play 20-0 — Draft nine and chase a perfect NFL season — regular season and playoffs, undefeated.
  • Play 16-0 — Draft nine and chase a perfect 16-0 — the classic 16-game NFL regular season, no playoffs.
  • Play Flawless Six — Draft five players and a head coach, then chase a perfect NFL season with the right chemistry.
  • Play Guess the NFL Player — A new mystery NFL player every day. Eight guesses, with a clue on each — plus free unlimited mode.
  • Play NFL Wordle — A Wordle for football — guess the daily NFL player in eight tries, with green-amber-grey feedback on every clue.
  • Play NFL Connections — Sort sixteen football tiles into four hidden groups of four. A new daily puzzle, four mistakes allowed, plus unlimited mode.
  • Explore all our games →

Related nfl guides

View all →
File photo from January 2018: Roquan Smith at a media day during the College Football Playoff. It was not taken in the Bills game and does not show either hit.
NFL

Roquan Smith Fined $35,822 for Two Unflagged Hits on Bills

The NFL fined Ravens linebacker Roquan Smith $17,911 twice for two unflagged plays against the Bills: a facemask on Josh Allen and a hit on DJ Moore.

A generic football head coach seen from behind on a night sideline, wearing a headset and watching a field goal attempt near the goalposts in a floodlit stadium, editorial graphic. AI-generated illustration, not SoFi Stadium or any real coach.
NFL

McVay Says He Is 'Sick' After Settling for the Kick That Was Blocked in Overtime

Sean McVay blamed himself for a conservative third-down run that set up Harrison Mevis's blocked 48-yard kick in the Rams' 37-34 overtime loss to Buffalo.

File photo from March 2026: Jets safety Minkah Fitzpatrick speaks to local media after being traded to New York. It does not show the Raiders game or Rex Ryan's radio appearance.
NFL

Rex Ryan Tells Minkah Fitzpatrick 'Adios' After Viral 'Jets Being Jets' Comment

Former Jets coach Rex Ryan tore into safety Minkah Fitzpatrick on ESPN New York after Fitzpatrick's postgame 'Jets being Jets' line went viral, even after the team said he misspoke.

File photo from 9 January 2022: Xavier McKinney, in a New York Giants No. 29 jersey, chases Washington running back Antonio Gibson at MetLife Stadium. It was not taken at the Lions game and does not show the fine or the officiating dispute.
NFL

McKinney Fined $25,000 for Blasting Officials After Packers' Lions Loss

The NFL fined Packers safety Xavier McKinney $25,000 for his post-game criticism of the officials after Green Bay's 20-17 loss at Detroit, a fine McKinney says was worth it.

File photo from 5 December 2021: Josh Jacobs carrying the ball for the Las Vegas Raiders against Washington at Allegiant Stadium. It was not taken at Green Bay and does not show the Carolina game or the touchdown celebration.
NFL

Josh Jacobs Says Packers Celebration Was Break Every Chain, Not a Handcuffs Mime

Josh Jacobs says the cameras caught one second of a planned gospel-song celebration after his touchdown against Carolina, and that fans read a handcuffs mime into a routine he planned with Savion Williams.

File photo from May 2026 of Jim Nantz speaking at a podium. It does not show Sunday's CBS broadcast or the punch. The 16:9 cropped derivative is offered under the same CC BY 4.0 licence.
NFL

Jim Nantz Hurt His Wrist Punching a Ball Out of J.J. Watt's Hands on Live TV

Jim Nantz punched a ball J.J. Watt was holding during the Bills-Raiders broadcast, clutched his wrist, joked it was broken and finished the game with an ice pack.