Draisaitl Cross-Checks Matthews in the Ribs and Gets No Penalty as Leafs Win 7-2
On this page5
The incident lasted a second and the argument will last the week. It happened off a faceoff, in the first period, between the two most watched centres in the game, and the official watching it kept his arm down. That is why a routine regular-season blowout became a referendum on officiating.
What exactly happened in the first shift?
Draisaitl caught Matthews with a hard cross-check to the ribs, Sportskeeda reports, and Sportsnet’s game report places it in Matthews’s first shift against Draisaitl. Matthews looked visibly uncomfortable after the hit, the same report notes, but he kept playing. The context matters: this was not a scrum, a retaliation, or a play at the boards where a stick can ride up by accident. It was a faceoff play, in open ice, with a referee looking at it, and the whistle never came. Sportskeeda is explicit on that point, and it is the point the whole debate turns on. A missed call in a pile is forgivable. A missed call in plain view, on a star, is not.
What did Bieksa say, and why does it matter?
He called it what the fans were already calling it, with the authority of a former defenceman. On Sportsnet’s post-game broadcast, Bieksa said there was a little bit of ruthlessness in the game and described the play precisely: a cross-check off the draw that gets Matthews right in the spot where there is no equipment, a really sneaky, dirty play. That framing matters because it removes the two usual defences. It was not a hockey play gone wrong, in Bieksa’s telling, and it was not soft. It was a targeted shot at an unprotected spot, delivered by a player who knew exactly where it would land. When a broadcaster says that on the rights-holder’s own air, the league’s silence becomes a decision rather than an oversight.
How did Matthews answer?
By doing the thing that makes the incident look worse for Edmonton, not better. Sportsnet reports Matthews contained hockey’s best line at five-on-five after the hit, and The Leafs Nation notes he scored a decisive goal off the rush, taking an Easton Cowan feed and finishing for a 2-0 lead in the second period. Toronto’s win was comprehensive: William Nylander scored twice, including his 300th career goal, Jack Roslovic added a goal and an assist, and Anthony Stolarz stopped 30 shots for first-star honours. The Leafs have now won four regulation games in a row, and their record as visitors in Edmonton since Matthews entered the league in 2016-17 is a lopsided 12-2-1, Sportsnet reports. Draisaitl, for his part, scored both Oilers goals in the loss, which makes the night stranger: the player at the centre of the incident was also his team’s only offence, and he finished without a single penalty minute.
Why are Leafs fans treating this as a pattern?
Because they have a file of them, and this one fits it too neatly. The fan reaction Sportskeeda collected split between two camps, one calling Draisaitl dirty and one calling the Leafs soft, but the through-line was enforcement: the league says it watches cross-checking closely, yet cross-checks to the head, neck and ribs keep going uncalled. Toronto fans have made this complaint before, and the desk has covered the other side of it too, from a hit that drew no penalty and a practice the next day to a hat trick sealed by a blocked shot into an empty net in a game where the physical tone never boiled over. The difference here is the stage: two Hart Trophy winners, a Saturday night, a national audience, and a referee with a clear view. If that one goes uncalled, fans reasonably ask which ones get called.
What happens next?
The Department of Player Safety decides whether a no-call ends the matter, and recent history says it does not have to. Frank Nazar drew a two-game suspension for a head check in his hearing, while Evan Rodrigues escaped with a maximum fine when his stick jab was downgraded in his case. Draisaitl’s play sits between those two poles: no head contact, no injury reported, but a deliberate stick to an unprotected area, in plain view, by a repeat star. The Oilers and the Leafs have both stayed quiet so far, and Matthews has said nothing about the hit beyond playing through it. The next signal will come from the league, and if it comes as silence, that will be read as an answer too. Either way, the clip is already the week’s exhibit in the argument about what the NHL actually polices, and the next time a cross-check draws a whistle, someone will post this one beside it. Matthews’ next game kept the officiating argument going in a different form: in Calgary two nights later, he reached 800 career points and then questioned a delay-of-game call for playing the puck with his hand off a faceoff as the Leafs lost 5-2.
Frequently asked questions
What did Draisaitl do to Matthews?+
He delivered a hard cross-check to Matthews's ribs during the first period on Saturday, Sportskeeda reports. Sportsnet's game report puts it in the captain's very first shift against Draisaitl, describing it as a nasty cross-check to the ribs. Matthews looked visibly uncomfortable after the hit but stayed in the game.
Was a penalty called on the play?+
No. Sportskeeda reports no penalty was called even though the referee had a clear view of the incident, and that is the detail driving the argument. The play happened off a faceoff, in open ice, with an official watching, and the game carried on without a whistle for it.
What did Kevin Bieksa say about the hit?+
That it was a sneaky, dirty play. Appearing on Sportsnet's post-game broadcast, Bieksa said there was a little bit of ruthlessness in the game and that the cross-check off the draw caught Matthews right in the spot where there is no equipment. His verdict gave the fan argument a mainstream voice: this was not incidental contact, it was a choice.
How did Matthews respond on the ice?+
By scoring and shutting down the Oilers' top line. Sportsnet reports Matthews contained hockey's best line at five-on-five after the hit, and The Leafs Nation notes he scored a decisive goal off the rush, taking an Easton Cowan feed and finishing for a 2-0 lead in the second period. Toronto won 7-2, its fourth regulation win in a row.
Did Draisaitl do anything else in the game?+
He scored both Edmonton goals in the loss, Sportskeeda reports, which is the other half of the night's story. The Oilers' most prolific scorer was both the villain of the incident and his team's only offence, and he finished the game without a penalty minute to his name.
Will the NHL review the cross-check?+
Nothing has been announced. The Department of Player Safety routinely reviews plays the officials miss, and the desk's recent cases show the range: Frank Nazar drew a two-game suspension for a head check in [his hearing](/nazar-match-penalty-horvat-hit-islanders/), while Evan Rodrigues escaped with a maximum fine when his stick jab was downgraded in [his case](/rodrigues-fined-5000-rossi-spear-downgraded/). A no-call on the ice does not end the matter.
Why are Leafs fans so angry about this one?+
Because it fits a pattern they have been arguing about for years. Sportskeeda's fan reaction split between those calling Draisaitl dirty and those calling the Leafs soft, but the recurring complaint was about enforcement: the league says it watches cross-checking closely, yet more cross-checks to the head, neck and ribs seem to go uncalled. A star-on-star incident, in plain view, with no whistle, is the worst possible exhibit for that argument.
Sources
- Sportsnet: Maple Leafs get full team effort in blowout win over McDavid's Oilers (the first-shift cross-check, the 7-2 result, Nylander's 300th, Stolarz's 30 saves)
- Sportskeeda: Fans debate Draisaitl's cross-check on Matthews (no penalty despite a clear view, Matthews visibly uncomfortable, Bieksa's 'sneaky, dirty play' verdict, Draisaitl's two goals)
- The Leafs Nation: 5 takeaways from Leafs-Oilers (Matthews shaking off the hit, the Cowan-feed goal for 2-0, the four-game winning streak)
Play & tools
Free browser games and tools — no account, no download.
- Play 98-0 — Draft a 12-player all-time NHL roster and chase a perfect 98-0 — 82 regular-season wins plus a swept Cup.
- Explore all our games →
Related ice hockey guides
View all →
Cowan Says 'I Cost Us the Game' as Matthews Disputes Hand Penalty in Leafs' 5-2 Loss
Easton Cowan blamed himself for Toronto's 5-2 loss at Calgary after a turnover and a roughing minor, while Auston Matthews questioned a delay-of-game call on a faceoff hand pass on the night he reached 800 career points.
McKenna Scores the Winner as Leafs Beat Sharks 3-1 in First Meeting With Stenberg
Gavin McKenna scored his first power-play goal, the winner at 4:56 of the third, in his first NHL meeting with No. 2 pick Ivar Stenberg as Toronto beat San Jose 3-1.
Hiller Calls Raddysh's Penalty 'Stupid' After It Costs Maple Leafs Against Utah
Toronto coach Jim Hiller did not hide behind coach-speak after a 3-2 loss to Utah, calling Darren Raddysh's third-period cross-checking penalty stupid and saying it cost his team, and Raddysh agreed.
Tavares' Tying Goal Wiped Out on Review as Leafs Lose 1-0 to Oilers
John Tavares had a tying goal wiped out for a high stick after a four-minute review as Toronto lost 1-0 to Edmonton and finished a winless homestand.
Hiller Says Benching McKenna Was His Mistake as the Leafs Blow a 4-2 Lead
Gavin McKenna played 6:36 and sat the final 32:54 of Toronto's overtime loss to Buffalo. Coach Jim Hiller says the benching was his error, not the rookie's.
Ekman-Larsson Leaves on a Lauzon Hit With No Penalty, Then Practices a Day Later
Oliver Ekman-Larsson left Toronto's loss in Vegas late on a Jeremy Lauzon hit that drew no penalty. He was back on the practice ice on Friday.